Vietnamese people are lost han chinese ? Options

[Q57]

I am just wondering whether vietnamese are actually han chinese who have lost their identity ?

You are so similar to the chinese in terms of

1. You have chinese surnames even after one thousand years of independence from china.

2. You willongly embraced our religion, culture, clothing and traditions.

3. You look like Chinese.

4. You eat chinese style food.

This post has been edited by Q57: Nov 1 2005, 06:14 AM

[southernstar]

And you're an idiot.

[viet-storian]

I am just wondering whether  vietnamese are actually han chinese who have lost their identity ?

You are so similar to the chinese in terms of

1. You have chinese surnames even after one thousand years of independence from china.

2. You willongly embraced our religion, culture, clothing and traditions.

3. You look like Chinese.

4. You eat chinese style food.

Viet and Han is different.

http://goldsea.com/Poll/CHMVF/chmvf_20526.html

[viet-storian]

I am just wondering whether  vietnamese are actually han chinese who have lost their identity ?

You are so similar to the chinese in terms of

1. You have chinese surnames even after one thousand years of independence from china.

2. You willongly embraced our religion, culture, clothing and traditions.

3. You look like Chinese.

4. You eat chinese style food.

Viet and Han is different.

http://goldsea.com/Poll/CHMVF/chmvf_20526.html

the vietnamese are originally considered to be the Yueh (viet or kinh), who were indigenous or native to where South and SouthEastern China is today. In no way were they related to the Han.....

[DavidChen]

I am just wondering whether  vietnamese are actually han chinese who have lost their identity ?

You are so similar to the chinese in terms of

1. You have chinese surnames even after one thousand years of independence from china.

2. You willongly embraced our religion, culture, clothing and traditions.

3. You look like Chinese.

4. You eat chinese style food.

Viet and Han is different.

http://goldsea.com/Poll/CHMVF/chmvf_20526.html

the vietnamese are originally considered to be the Yueh (viet or kinh), who were indigenous or native to where South and SouthEastern China is today. In no way were they related to the Han.....

then they are related to cambodians ?

[viet-storian]

I am just wondering whether  vietnamese are actually han chinese who have lost their identity ?

You are so similar to the chinese in terms of

1. You have chinese surnames even after one thousand years of independence from china.

2. You willongly embraced our religion, culture, clothing and traditions.

3. You look like Chinese.

4. You eat chinese style food.

Viet and Han is different.

http://goldsea.com/Poll/CHMVF/chmvf_20526.html

the vietnamese are originally considered to be the Yueh (viet or kinh), who were indigenous or native to where South and SouthEastern China is today. In no way were they related to the Han.....

then they are related to cambodians ?

Austroasiatic: (Vietnamese, Cambodian), Daic (Thai), and Miao-Yao families of southeast Asia--recently lumped together with Austronesian as a single superfamily.

[DavidChen]

so basically you guys are like cambodians , until the chinese came then you became lighter skinned. makes sense.

[viet-storian]

Austroasiatic is how our languages are similar. But for physicall appearance you guys are more related to indoneasian,thai, laos and Cham people in central vietnam.

"The viets lived in that area originally and have been recorded to even in the chinese annals. They then moved south to where vietnam is now (northern vietnam) because of the invading chinese (Han).The viets don't have Han in their blood (or atleast most viets don't). It is commonly believed that the southerners have less of a circle face, and has more of a heart shaped face, also leaner in body structure, brighter and lighter in skin, with bigger eyes and more double eyelids. It is possible that the Yueh line gave the southern chinese this (as it is written in chinese annals that the viets had these traits along with a whole bunch of stuff concerning the toes,toes thing too long, so someone else can right it if another is curious). The vietnamese have these traits too."

http://goldsea.com/Poll/CHMVF/chmvf_20526.html

[DavidChen]

Austroasiatic is how our languages are similar. But for physicall appearance you guys are more related to indoneasian,thai, laos and Cham people in central vietnam.

"The viets lived in that area originally and have been recorded to even in the chinese annals. They then moved south to where vietnam is now (northern vietnam) because of the invading chinese (Han).The viets don't have Han in their blood (or atleast most viets don't). It is commonly believed that the southerners have less of a circle face, and has more of a heart shaped face, also leaner in body structure, brighter and lighter in skin, with bigger eyes and more double eyelids. It is possible that the Yueh line gave the southern chinese this (as it is written in chinese annals that the viets had these traits along with a whole bunch of stuff concerning the toes,toes thing too long, so someone else can right it if another is curious). The vietnamese have these traits too."

http://goldsea.com/Poll/CHMVF/chmvf_20526.html

so it must of branched off from some cambodian tribes that moved north then moved back down.

[intestine_treasu...]

i want to be cambodian

[DavidChen]

Well the move south aborbed the khmer and cham into the vietnamese, but is only evident in the south. The central and northern area was free of khmer and cham, hence the reason for the lighter skin.

[DavidChen]

ok i get it ,

so basically chinese mix with cambodians equals = vietnamese

in that case , you guys were a bunch of mistakes. because for han chinese to have sex with cambodians is to me very low class. i guess there was no form of abortion when it happened so vietnamese spread thru the south

[GenomVirues]

Talking about mistake, i guess we have something in common with Chinese women. Heh Heh

[Asian Masturbati...]

ok i get it ,

so basically chinese mix with cambodians equals = vietnamese

in that case , you guys were a bunch of mistakes. because for han chinese to have sex with cambodians is to me very low class. i guess there was no form of abortion when it happened so vietnamese spread thru the south

^ WTF in ur dreams buddy

[PhoShizzle]

another useless thread

[VietSk8rGUI]

ok i get it ,

so basically chinese mix with cambodians equals = vietnamese

in that case , you guys were a bunch of mistakes. because for han chinese to have sex with cambodians is to me very low class. i guess there was no form of abortion when it happened so vietnamese spread thru the south

傻瓜 去地狱!!!!!!!!!!! -

This post has been edited by VietSk8rGUI: Nov 1 2005, 09:19 AM

[RiDer oN ThE RoA...]

no fu-king way
hans were originated from north west china and move to huang he ville in north central china.

[dolongdao]

davidchen: quit insulting cambodians u sino supremacist
i think of you as being extremely low class as a result of displaying such primitive ignorance in a modern society

[neinei]

viet and han are different, but viet can be considered a lost yeuh tribe that never assimiliated into the Han

as for viet being cambodian, NO...we are in noway related to them, we didnt even have contact with them since Champa was blocking our way til 1300's, but i have done some research, and i see alot of cambodians say that china and and cambodia are long lost blood brothers

[CoDep]

All Asians are long lost brothers sisters from Africa .
However, Vietnamese and Cambodians are closer relatives than Chinese.
We are brothers and sisters dozens of thousands of years ago.
At that time, people in Vietnam and China are tribes without a nation.
The Chinese came to Vietnam only 2 or 3 thousands of years ago.

It does not means that a person can say "Vietnamese = Chinese + Cambodian"
This reasoning and thinking is some kind of low self esteem.

About skin color: The Chinese have brighter and lighter skin than the Vietnamese.
You are more correct saying about the face, the eye lids, and body built.