Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: If Koreans eat dogs openly...
Asia Finest Discussion Forum > Asian Culture > Filipino Chat
azrach187
Korea, where kegogi (cooked dog) is a delicacy and vendors come out at night to sell "dog food" and eat it openly. The Philippine tradition of eating dogs could be pinpointed at around the 70's (because of marshal law?) maybe due to poverty.

So why, is it still taboo to talk about eating dogs in some part of the country and even overseas? I see nothing wrong with it (I've eaten it).
dalawapo
because koreans have a culture that will counteract savage perception of dog eater, but filipine doent have a culture to counter act savage perception... because filipine culture is higly dependent on spanish culture as a civilizing savlation.....
azrach187
QUOTE(dalawapo @ Dec 15 2006, 02:36 AM) [snapback]2571932[/snapback]

because koreans have a culture that will counteract savage perception of dog eater, but filipine doent have a culture to counter act savage perception... because filipine culture is higly dependent on spanish culture as a civilizing savlation.....

And who made you expert on the Philippines? MR. I-Want-to-Be-Guamanian-so-Bad-I-hated-my-Filipino Ancestry guy. Funny.

You're not even Guamanian. And you sure as hell ain't Filipino. Stay off Filipino forums, wanna be.
Reilynx
I think it's because Filipinos are altruistic, unlike other Asians. We care too much about what others would think.

One reason is westerners find it icky when dogs and cats are eaten.

Watch how some condemn the Koreans for eating dogs and cats.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ISyfQodfl0o
azrach187
QUOTE(Reilynx @ Dec 15 2006, 03:31 AM) [snapback]2572041[/snapback]

I think it's because Filipinos are altruistic, unlike other Asians. We care too much about what others would think.

I agree. Being an Ilocano, we eat things that might be disgusting to outsiders that I could consider a mark of who I am, giving no care what people think.

Dinuguan, sawa, bayawak, palaka, etc. are delicacies I very much enjoy when I'm home in the province.
Reilynx
It's animal meat, just like beef, pork and chicken. It's just a matter of preference I guess. I don't know why some westerners would go ape sh!t about it. embarassedlaugh.gif
greenrice88
actually, there are some places where eating dogs is practically normal. i saw on tv that in baguio and ilocos, it is eaten traditionally. they even use it in marriages
TakTAk-Boy
i actually dotn see any deff between the koreans and filipinos when it comes to dog eating. Some parts of the Phil are open to dog eating while others arent same with koreans. and Koreans arent exactly advertising to everyone in the world that they eat dogs. i got korean friends who leave the dog eating part as part of Korean cuisine.
peanutbutterjelly
QUOTE(dalawapo @ Dec 14 2006, 10:36 PM) [snapback]2571932[/snapback]

because koreans have a culture that will counteract savage perception of dog eater, but filipine doent have a culture to counter act savage perception... because filipine culture is higly dependent on spanish culture as a civilizing savlation.....




Go back to school and learn how to spell - and then get lynched...hard.
R3M1X
I'm from baguio in the Philippines. i remember my uncle coming home w/ dog meat one night.. actually had a taste. no difference. just the ethnic/moral/cultural issues of peoples prespective that is.

i was about 8-9 years old then. even though meat is meat i'd rather stick to things that i don't have as pets at home. if we went "Survival" about this issue then i don't think nebody would be complaining. it isn't really the issue then it seems wrong.

usually when u kill to eat an animal.. u kill cook n eat it.. torturing n all that $hit just isn't right.

most of the time it's only taboo because other societies do not understand the culture. (though that korea thing they could atleast just kill the damn thing.. sadistic)

BatangDamo
QUOTE(azrach187 @ Dec 15 2006, 01:49 AM) [snapback]2571972[/snapback]

And who made you expert on the Philippines? MR. I-Want-to-Be-Guamanian-so-Bad-I-hated-my-Filipino Ancestry guy. Funny.




Umm, imma have to go with azrach187 on this one. I think real Filipinos should know more about this
azyanghost
i use to eat dogs and cats when i was small and never thought about this things.it becomes diffrent when you get americanized and start seeing things from western perspective.
DestinationUnknown
TROLL BANNED owned.gif
Genesis of Ire
And don't they kill hundreds of dogs in the American pounds as well? I still wouldn't eat a dog, but it's not as if Americans don't slaughter these animals either.
dalawapo
QUOTE(azrach187 @ Dec 15 2006, 02:49 AM) [snapback]2571972[/snapback]

And who made you expert on the Philippines? MR. I-Want-to-Be-Guamanian-so-Bad-I-hated-my-Filipino Ancestry guy. Funny.

You're not even Guamanian. And you sure as hell ain't Filipino. Stay off Filipino forums, wanna be.


Oh?? i must be under the limbo stick if im not chamorro or filipine but one thing for sure your surely under the uglee stick! laugh.gif

also i dont really mind, its my opinons anyways so what if im not an expert on eating dogs like you! shrug.gif
DestinationUnknown
owned.gif Troll Banned
Ino_II
sigh.... a lot of koreans dont eat dogs. since korea itself is becoming more westernized, the young generation views the practice as barbaric and uncivilized. many animal rights groups have protested and the situation is changing (thank god). eat dog openly? vendors? overexaggerated.

on the other hand, there is nothing really wrong with eating dogs. its an animal, white people need to look at themselves before pointing fingers.
Oyabun
who gives a $hit about eating dog meat? a dog is an animal, animals are meant to be eaten or worn, French people eat ostriches and horses, Americans eat chickens and cows and pigs. the dogs eaten anyways are raised to be eaten it's not like they are people's pets and then they just kill them and cook them, PETA are a bunch of fags.
Ino_II
QUOTE(Oyabun @ Dec 15 2006, 04:24 PM) [snapback]2573251[/snapback]

PETA are a bunch of fags.


right on bro biggthumpup.gif


angela_gandaDAW
QUOTE(dalawapo @ Dec 14 2006, 10:36 PM) [snapback]2571932[/snapback]

because koreans have a culture that will counteract savage perception of dog eater, but filipine doent have a culture to counter act savage perception... because filipine culture is higly dependent on spanish culture as a civilizing savlation.....



Why do you hate the philippines so much? what is wrong with you?!

QUOTE(DestinationUnknown @ Dec 15 2006, 12:39 PM) [snapback]2573180[/snapback]

owned.gif Troll Banned


you are disgusting love2.gif
Oyabun
QUOTE(Ino_II @ Dec 15 2006, 04:33 PM) [snapback]2573264[/snapback]

right on bro biggthumpup.gif



they are a bunch of plant eating homosexuals, a plant would eat them if it had the chance. laugh.gif
Psycho John
I'm sick of westeners always judging others. As if everything done in the west is the standard. We are not to judge others. I know other countries who think we're crazy for eating beef and pork, but we see nothing wrong with it. Why don't we all just respect one anothers culture?
filipino_boy
lol u knoe why? each groups think theyre the best. some filipino think filipino is the best ethnic group, theres the kkk cracker power, and whatever.

oh how do dogs taste like? are they good?
Ino_II
QUOTE(filipino_boy @ Dec 15 2006, 06:06 PM) [snapback]2573446[/snapback]


oh how do dogs taste like? are they good?


ive never tasted it, none of my family has ever tasted it, and never will..
DestinationUnknown
owned.gif Troll Banned
Ino_II
QUOTE(DestinationUnknown @ Dec 15 2006, 08:36 PM) [snapback]2573779[/snapback]

owned.gif Troll Banned

so? alot of asian groups eat it. china for example.
Kian Seng
I can see why Americans see dog eating as offensive, they think about their cute Golden Retriver sleeping on their bed being eatin by people. But I don't think its right to judge Filipinos or any culture as disgusting. When I was small I remember hearing about how the Chinese people eat sea turtles and I was sickened. Vut even at a young age I knew not to hate the people that eat turtles, their hungry they have meat and they eat it thats the way we should all see it.

Ps- I don't eat dog.
azrach187
QUOTE(dalawapo @ Dec 15 2006, 05:00 PM) [snapback]2573213[/snapback]

Oh?? i must be under the limbo stick if im not chamorro or filipine but one thing for sure your surely under the uglee stick! laugh.gif

also i dont really mind, its my opinons anyways so what if im not an expert on eating dogs like you! shrug.gif

Idiot. You have a lot of room to speak about appearances, unknown to you, I read between the lines. What's wrong? Scared to post pictures? I know, because you're one ugly mother, who after all is said and done, looks like a Filipino you so hate. I have enough pictures posted in this site that I could care less if you call me ugly, I compensate with good looking girls, I go out with.

Opinions my dear, is calling a glass with water, half-empty or half-full. Calling a hill a mountain is just plain stupidity. You my dear, is stupid. And that's not an opinion. That's what you call fact.

Try me. I will put you on your place. bawling.gif

biggrin.gif
Balot
QUOTE(DestinationUnknown @ Dec 15 2006, 03:39 PM) [snapback]2573180[/snapback]

Troll Banned owned.gif


you think so? then what are you? biggthumpup.gif
Balot
QUOTE(DestinationUnknown @ Dec 15 2006, 03:39 PM) [snapback]2573180[/snapback]

Troll Banned owned.gif


you think so? then what are you? biggthumpup.gif
Goombaking209
QUOTE(Kian Seng @ Dec 15 2006, 06:16 PM) [snapback]2573877[/snapback]

I can see why Americans see dog eating as offensive, they think about their cute Golden Retriver sleeping on their bed being eatin by people. But I don't think its right to judge Filipinos or any culture as disgusting. When I was small I remember hearing about how the Chinese people eat sea turtles and I was sickened. Vut even at a young age I knew not to hate the people that eat turtles, their hungry they have meat and they eat it thats the way we should all see it.

Ps- I don't eat dog.


i have had turtle once. it wasnt all that great .. their meat is yellow
kermit_criminal
QUOTE(DestinationUnknown @ Dec 15 2006, 04:03 PM) [snapback]2573221[/snapback]

Troll Banned owned.gif


hey be quite or il cut your head off, we do that sort of thing here. barbaric huh?
etano
Dog eating is very common in Korea and Vietnam and its popularity is growing in China and Philippines.
Most westerners view dog eating negatively because dogs have been kept as pets and as men's good friends for centuries. In those countries, dogs are specially bred for consumption which I think it is acceptabe but I don't agree someone eating their pet dogs.
phichanad
not all filipinos eat dogs and cats, like me. It does not mean that if a Filipino eat a dog or cat, it means they eat their pets.

Thais even eat cockroaches, worms, bugs, same for the chinese and many other nationalities. But was is wrong with that? That's their culture.
BatangDamo
Getting out of hand, closing
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2009 Invision Power Services, Inc.