Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Pinoy voters remain immature - NSCB study
Asia Finest Discussion Forum > Asian Culture > Filipino Chat
agentslayer
http://www.gmanews.tv/story/32354/Pinoy-vo...re---NSCB-study


QUOTE
Voting for the same wrong candidates seems to be a hard habit to break for Pinoy voters. After participating in numerous national and local elections for decades, Filipinos have yet to gain wisdom from the political exercise, GMANews.TV learned Tuesday.

A study by Dr. Romulo A. Virola, secretary general of the National Statistics and Coordination Board, showed that there were still voters who re-elected local public officials who had failed to develop the economy of their province.

The study is posted on the NSCB website.

Using data from the 2004 elections, the study came up with a voters’ index that provided indication on the “wisdom" of voters during elections.

This means the index measures whether voters are reelecting candidates in the best and best performing (provinces) and booting out those who are in the worst performing provinces.

In the study, Virola confirmed that “indeed, Filipino voters have not matured" because candidates whose provinces “do badly in the good government index, get reelected just the same."

Statistical data in the study showed that 20 percent of 2004 election voters reelected candidates in 10 worst provinces; 15 percent reelected candidates in the 20 worst provinces and 23 percent in worst 30 provinces.

Meanwhile, there were 22 percent who re-elected candidates in 10 worst performing provinces, 26 percent in 20 worst performing provinces and 24 percent in the 30 worst provinces.

Instead of coming up with the worst and worst performing provinces, the study listed the first 30 best provinces and 30 best performing provinces that attained highest rates in the good governance index.

“Congratulations to those provinces and to their leaders. Those not on the list [try to] grab every chance to catch up and improve [next time]," said Virola in the study.

The first 10 best provinces under the good governance index are: Batanes, Rizal, Laguna, Bulacan, Cavite, Bataan, Benguet, Siquijor, Apayao and Pampanga.

The first 10 best performing provinces are: Siquijor, Northern samara, Oriental Mindoro, Agusan del Sur, Zamboanga Sibugay, Bukidnon, Aklan, Surigao del Norte, Eastern Samar and Basilan.

In measuring the good governance index of provinces, the study used economic and administrative governance indicators.

Economic governance was measured in terms of the following indicators: per capita financial resources generated, per capita tax and non-tax revenue, per capita bank deposits, per capita expenditure on social services, unemployment and underemployment rates, poverty incidence and poverty gap.

Administrative governance was measured through these indicators: total health personnel per thousand population, percentage of live births weighing less than 250 grams, proportion of households with access to safe water, teacher to pupil ration for elementary schools, number of elementary schools per thousand population, enrolment in government elementary schools per thousand population, cohort survival rate in elementary education, percentage of housing made of strong roofs, percentage of housing made of strong walls, length of national and local roads per thousand population, proportion of energized barangays and telephone density. - GMANews.TV


I still love it that "corruption" is almost a routine excuse for many when in fact, many people are themselves to blame in many instances. Corruption exists, but copping out and voting for the same crooks when there are competent and virgin candidates is just sad.

And what the fu-k dude, why do people keep on voting celebrities, washed up actors and sports stars into public office????? The whole Pacquaio thing saddens me.

"Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice, shame on me."
Love*3
This is offensive. There is no right or wrong. You can't call someone immature just because they don't vote for the best cadidates according to some chart. Humans make the chart.
jhonnz
QUOTE(Love*3 @ Feb 27 2007, 05:36 PM) [snapback]2754789[/snapback]

This is offensive. There is no right or wrong. You can't call someone immature just because they don't vote for the best cadidates according to some chart. Humans make the chart.


offensive as it may seem but the truth really hurts. a lot of Filipinos are still stupid voters. that's a fact.
ham_let
QUOTE(agentslayer @ Feb 27 2007, 04:59 PM) [snapback]2754608[/snapback]

[And what the fu-k dude, why do people keep on voting celebrities, washed up actors and sports stars into public office????? The whole Pacquaio thing saddens me.

exactly. embarassedlaugh.gif

you'd tihnk people would've gotten a clue after the whole ERAP deal. icon_confused.gif
kurt123
Good news about Manny Pacquiao! If I heard the news correctly, he is seriously reconsidering his decision to run in the coming elections and there is a big chance he might withdraw, due to some of his fans expressing their dissatisfaction about his decision to run. Hopefully he does the right thing and stick with boxing.
poknat
Good News for Manny Pacquiao ! He will not run for Congress in General Santos
jargalant
Yeey! My home province (Bulacan) is one of the 10 best provinces! beerchug.gif

I think this also reflect the educational background of the people of the said worst provinces. These provinces unfortunately are provinces with low percentage of literacy among its people.
flipcombatmedic
no offense, but you can't blame half of these people. yes, some of them are less educated, but who's fault is that? Me and you who fu-king welcome crappy entertainment, shallow movies and elevated "artists" with no talents and paid those cops the bribe money instead of saying "then give me the damn ticket!".

This is a democracy isn't it? That's what we get. I don't think it's too late. but as usual the blame is passed on to those that get half plate full. blame those who were neglected and call them "immature" when all of US who had been given more than enough probably welcomed the thought of a Manny Pacquiao as well or another People's Power, yet when people of the province vote for them, we called them idiots. $hit we all watch ABS CBN!
xrough
QUOTE(flipcombatmedic @ Feb 28 2007, 03:35 PM) [snapback]2756087[/snapback]

no offense, but you can't blame half of these people. yes, some of them are less educated, but who's fault is that? Me and you who fu-king welcome crappy entertainment, shallow movies and elevated "artists" with no talents and paid those cops the bribe money instead of saying "then give me the damn ticket!".

This is a democracy isn't it? That's what we get. I don't think it's too late. but as usual the blame is passed on to those that get half plate full. blame those who were neglected and call them "immature" when all of US who had been given more than enough probably welcomed the thought of a Manny Pacquiao as well or another People's Power, yet when people of the province vote for them, we called them idiots. $hit we all watch ABS CBN!



Everyone it entitled to their own conscience, if they vote for someone who we thought that is not deserving so be it..and what we can now is vote again in this coming election..let's vote wisely..btw, for me ABS-CBN so far the best station here in RP..
agentslayer
The author and whoever did the study probably used the term "immature" to refer to the youngness of Filipino democratic participation, not exactly as a way to offend people.

As much as politics in the Philippines is dysfunctional and quite a mess, I agree with you, flipcombatmedic. I still treasure the fact that it's still a thriving democracy. After all, it's been only, like what, less than 50 years that we've actually able to do this on our own, so there are still traces of the old way of doing things. We loooooooove royalties or people who have royalty-like status because we were under some sort of monarchy(Maharlikas) for much of pre-hispanic Philippines. And when the Europeans came in, they did not exaclt help with things and in fact, made it worse.
Kanlungan
I don't think immature is the proper term. I don't know what the proper term is but it seems that Filipinos still go for those who are openly corrupt.

I'm starting to think if this is brought about the multi-party system.

Loy and Jinggoy are Senators
Bongbong Marcos is the governor of Ilocos Norte
Chavit Singson is the Governor of Ilocos Sur

flipcombatmedic
QUOTE(Kanlungan @ Mar 13 2007, 03:48 AM) [snapback]2788344[/snapback]

I don't think immature is the proper term. I don't know what the proper term is but it seems that Filipinos still go for those who are openly corrupt.

I'm starting to think if this is brought about the multi-party system.

Loy and Jinggoy are Senators
Bongbong Marcos is the governor of Ilocos Norte
Chavit Singson is the Governor of Ilocos Sur

what does different partidos do? most of the major ones are pretty much identical. the only difference is who knows who and who will pay for what.
salted_ham
From my POV, I think people hardly identify with the ideology of the party; but rather with their "favorite" candidate so they automatically go for the whole party. So it's becoming like those reality shows on TV.
maharlika
It is sad, yes.

They remain "immature" (regardless of what was meant, I don't care) for the very reason that political democratization usually takes more than a lifetime to be fully embedded. Since democracy takes a long time to take hold of the minds of individuals, from the time the Balanghais landed in Philippine beaches through the end of the Philippine-American War, Filipinos never had any sort of exposure to the concept of democracy. If the question we have right now is voting smartly, then one must understand that the circumstances surrounding those in the provinces are different from those we have in the urban areas. Mind you, year 2007 Philippines is year 1837 of the U.S. in terms of democratization.

We are used to favoring personality rather than the issues that should have been the focus of our political interactions. There are many cases where we favor the "rule of men" rather than "the rule of law." But you see, back then, leaders (or datus) are well more trusted than the usual politicians right now. Names such as Lapu-lapu, Humabon, Lakandula, and Matanda were names of respect and dignity to the people. The problem was, when the Spaniards came, legitimacy of power and authority was transferred from the said virtues to illusions of grandeur and divine right.

As of current, members of the privilege few of far away provinces are motivated to maintain the traditions and customs of the past detrimental to the principle of democracy because they benefit from it. It is just the same as the American Wild West where the laws of that time was survival or at least favor the fastest gun drawer or the quickest to hide. To each his own, I might add.

So, forgive us if we have not met the expectations of some, even the NCSB chairman. But we are changing. However, I refuse to use established western democracies as the standards of measuring how democratic the Philippines is. Filipinos in provinces remain under the influence and benefits of traditions and customs of the past whether they are good or bad, whether they are native or foreign. They were used to the sufferings inflicted by foreign conquerors to their forebears who taught them that suffering is a virtue that they must also suffer. But it is changing, even if it is slowly.

Utang na loob, pakikisama, and other surviving native traditions are twisted by those smart enough to manipulate the system so that they could benefit from it. I admit and I agree that democracy is good. But democracy is not an absolute good; hence, it cannot be said as a system of governance that only brings good things. It brings its own political deceases and unethical practices.








This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2009 Invision Power Services, Inc.