Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Convict's sentence: To serve God
Asia Finest Discussion Forum > Asian Culture > India Chat
Bihari
QUOTE
Patna: Convicted of rape and murder at the age of 12, Mantun Kumar was sentenced to five years imprisonment followed by six months' service at a temple by a court in the Begusarai district of Bihar.

And Kumar considers himself to be very lucky to serve the sentence, as it is a sentence to ‘serve God’.

Says Kumar,” I consider myself lucky as I am in the presence of God.”

Kumar in fact feels so indebted to the legal system that he now wants to help run the rule of law.

“In future I would like to do a respectable work. My desire is to become a police inspector,” says Kumar.

The temple authorities as well as worshippers also support the court verdict.

“The worst of human beings get reformed when they come before God. The court has made the right decision,” says manager, Mahavir Temple, Patna, Nagendra Ojha.

“I think the court's decision is right. He should be given a chance to reform himself,” adds a devotee, Rupa Sinha.

The unconventional sentence has no doubt given a new lease of life to Kumar. And with people supporting the court verdict, there is perhaps hope for many others like him as well.


http://www.ibnlive.com/news/convicts-sente...d/41972-13.html


what are your thoughts on this?

keep in mind:

he was 12 when the crimes were done.

but how can a 12 year old commit such horrible acts? could he be mentally ill so they have let him go lightly?

this is crazy
ExpressYourself
QUOTE(Bihari @ Jun 3 2007, 10:36 PM) *
http://www.ibnlive.com/news/convicts-sente...d/41972-13.html
what are your thoughts on this?

keep in mind:

he was 12 when the crimes were done.

but how can a 12 year old commit such horrible acts? could he be mentally ill so they have let him go lightly?

this is crazy



Is there any background information on his crime in detail? When I was 12, even a lot of American kids didn't even exactly know what "rape" is, so forget about them committing such an act.


There are stories of young kids stumbling upon real guns, start to naively play with them, and you know what happens afterwards. I'm feeling a bit nice to wonder if his crime aws accidental, or maybe he truly is that demented to do such a thing.
VAMAN
The topic starter have given link to it, kindly open it and read it, its a true story. That dude was 12 years old when he raped a girl. Now the judge has made him do community service in a temple, the sentence is itself unique but good that he has been given a chance to reform, there can't be more harsher punishment for a crime commited in that early age. Few days ago I saw this story in a News Channel on TV. The journalist even took an interview of that guy.
Najjiah
he's only 17 now & i have a feeling he's not reformed. he did this hideous crime at 12. five years is not even enough punishment.

i think the kid needs a therapists.

ExpressYourself
QUOTE(Najjiah @ Jun 4 2007, 01:14 PM) *
he's only 17 now & i have a feeling he's not reformed. he did this hideous crime at 12. five years is not even enough punishment.

i think the kid needs a therapists.



You got to be careful at how slick some of them are. They will say that they're sorry and that they deserve to die for their crimes, but they're full of crap and they're trying to elicit sympathy from you whilst getting on your good side. The only thing they're truly sorry for is that they were caught from what I've seen.

Here in the states, juveniles that commit crimes like that can get up to life sentences. If you commit an adult crime, you most likely will be tried as an adult. shrug.gif
Najjiah
QUOTE(ExpressYourself @ Jun 4 2007, 11:37 AM) *
You got to be careful at how slick some of them are. They will say that they're sorry and that they deserve to die for their crimes, but they're full of crap and they're trying to elicit sympathy from you whilst getting on your good side. The only thing they're truly sorry for is that they were caught from what I've seen.

Here in the states, juveniles that commit crimes like that can get up to life sentences. If you commit an adult crime, you most likely will be tried as an adult. shrug.gif

as it should be. they should just incarcerate him and let him out at age 25 only after severe rehabilitation. for all we know this kid was being manipulative. its all too easy to say you've found god just to garner public sympathy. and wow it worked.

and yeah, dont we also notify the public if a sex offender/rapists gets out of jail and moves into your neighborhood?
ExpressYourself
QUOTE(Najjiah @ Jun 4 2007, 01:52 PM) *
as it should be. they should just incarcerate him and let him out at age 25 only after severe rehabilitation. for all we know this kid was being manipulative. its all too easy to say you've found god just to garner public sympathy. and wow it worked.

and yeah, dont we also notify the public if a sex offender/rapists gets out of jail and moves into your neighborhood?



Yeah, have you heard of this site?

http://www.familywatchdog.us/

It lets you locate sex offenders in your area AND it tells you what their crime was. I saw several Desi uncles in my town, but thank goodness they aren't our family friends.
Najjiah
QUOTE(ExpressYourself @ Jun 4 2007, 12:34 PM) *
Yeah, have you heard of this site?

http://www.familywatchdog.us/

It lets you locate sex offenders in your area AND it tells you what their crime was. I saw several Desi uncles in my town, but thank goodness they aren't our family friends.
holy shiat!!!!!

theres like a million in santa monica here in LA! omg. thats NASTY. eeew im moving.
Bihari
the article is not written well. it does not mention much about his crimes , which it should, so we know how he should be punished. and why he is being let off so easily.
jiggyiggy
This kid was nothing but slum slime, he should've been sent to pick the dead bodies off of Mount Everest.
Confuse
Such a hideous crime.
I think he should've been castrated.
Then he could serve god if the Legal system wished.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.