Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Building Collapses
Asia Finest Discussion Forum > Asian Culture > Filipino Chat
Ek-ek
Building collapses
in Divisoria
Posted: 10:45 PM (Manila Time) | Jul. 23, 2004
By Tarra V. Quismundo
Inquirer News Service

IN THE heart of busy Divisoria, Friday morning, a 5-year-old building began to lean, sending frightened passersby scampering for safety, bringing traffic and business to a halt, and pedestrians gawking for hours at the awesome sight of a structure about to crumble.

Six hours after a guard noticed the eight-story Sai Building on Padre Rada Street, Tondo, starting to tilt, the structure collapsed, damaging establishments nearby. There were no casualties.



The building collapsed at 4:40 p.m., crashing down on one side of the adjacent Italy Marketing building.

"It was like a glacier breaking up," said Manila Mayor Jose L. Atienza Jr., who had rushed to the scene 30 minutes before it came crashing down.

Atienza ordered police to secure the building round the clock, with the Insular Bank vault and other valuables under the rubble. The bank is one of the building's tenants.

Authorities have yet to determine the extent of the damages.

"We are looking at what happened and who should be held responsible -- the owner, the builder or the government. The good news is that nobody was hurt and we were prepared," said Atienza.

"As early as 10:30 a.m. we heard a loud sound, like a transformer had exploded," said Ernesto Ozaeta, a security guard at Insular bank. "When we went outside, we saw that the building had already tilted on its side."

A barangay watchman with a megaphone directed vendors, shoppers and passersby to get as far away from the building as possible.

Police learned about the leaning building shortly before noon. When they arrived at the scene, the immediate area around the building had already been cordoned off, and offices beside it empty.

"I felt the building had sunk after I heard a loud cracking sound," said Sai owner Ajit Mansukhani, referring to the same sound Ozaeta heard.

By 3 p.m., the building was already leaning some four feet to its right, its angle made apparent by the building's skewed distance from the structure behind it.

"The building's foundation may have weakened because there was construction work all around it. My assessment is that when workers began pounding to lay down the concrete piles, the soil structure underneath Sai had changed," said Harry Wong, an engineer and a friend of Mansukhani.

Two medium-rise buildings are under construction in front of Sai.

The building housed a few residential and office units, and a textile warehouse on the second floor. Mansukhani said that some 20 people stayed at the building at any given time.

Before it collapsed, occupants, including Insular personnel, were not allowed by the Bureau of Fire Protection to retrieve their belongings from their units.

A Jollibee branch and a bakery at Sai's ground floor were among the first establishments to close down.

The Metropolitan Manila Development Authority, the National Disaster Coordinating Council, the Manila City Government, and the Department of Public Works and Highways helped secure the area.

Starting Monday, Insular Bank clients can transact business at its Sta. Elena branch on 668 Sta. Elena street, said Jose Ernesto Villaluna, Insular vice president.

dalawapo
wow scarey! got any pictures? confused.gif
parok_mah
its a good thing that there are no casualties. people in that building saw the window glasses break and it triggered the evacuation.
Rocky Cuong V
*I pray for all those that die* "may the heaven gate be open for you to enter"
kim_kayie
QUOTE (Cuong @ Jul 24 2004, 09:08 AM)
*I pray for all those that die* "may the heaven gate be open for you to enter"

there are no casualties like parok said... but thanks for your concerns!
Rocky Cuong V
QUOTE (kim_kayie @ Jul 25 2004, 01:34 AM)
QUOTE (Cuong @ Jul 24 2004, 09:08 AM)
*I pray for all those that die* "may the heaven gate be open for you to enter"

there are no casualties like parok said... but thanks for your concerns!

These reporter bull$hit alot. I bet there is tones of death and distruction. There has to be......
kim_kayie
QUOTE (Cuong @ Jul 24 2004, 11:03 AM)
QUOTE (kim_kayie @ Jul 25 2004, 01:34 AM)
QUOTE (Cuong @ Jul 24 2004, 09:08 AM)
*I pray for all those that die* "may the heaven gate be open for you to enter"

there are no casualties like parok said... but thanks for your concerns!

These reporter bull$hit alot. I bet there is tones of death and distruction. There has to be......

well at least we should be thankful that no one was hurt
joonson
I was there in Divisoria when it happened... i was buying some materials to use for candle making.

Its really scary eek.gif cry2.gif
Emperor
QUOTE (dalawapo @ Jul 24 2004, 07:01 AM)
wow scarey! got any pictures? confused.gif



kim_kayie
QUOTE (joonson @ Jul 25 2004, 09:56 AM)
I was there in Divisoria when it happened... i was buying some materials to use for candle making.

Its really scary eek.gif cry2.gif

OMG! you really there! eek.gif
zayna
QUOTE (kim_kayie @ Jul 25 2004, 12:29 PM)
QUOTE (joonson @ Jul 25 2004, 09:56 AM)
I was there in Divisoria when it happened... i was buying some materials to use for candle making.

Its really scary eek.gif  cry2.gif

OMG! you really there! eek.gif

be thankful that nothing bad happened to you..
dalawapo
wouldnt it be safer to build buildings out of wood or something since the philippines is situtated in the ring of fire?

or what about architectually designed buildings to sustain earthquakes?
anjing
the authorities are still investigating about the case because as what the owner said the building stands for five years and nothing happened until the constructions beside them starts to put pipes...
I_YaH
e kasi pag mga ganyan na bldg e dapat hinuhulog na sa time space warp! ...ngayon din!
Bandcamp
just another example of poor filipino constrution
PuccaCC
weak foundations from my point of view.probably needed to be refubished altogther.its a lesson to constuct stronger buildings.
Bandcamp
i sure hope nobody was hurt
PuccaCC
no,no one was,apparently someone reported a creaking of the building and all ppl were evacuated.glad no one died from it.remember even if u hear the smallest of creaks,u should keep urself alert!!!
Bandcamp
your one hot chic puccacc, how bout posting more pics of yourself
PuccaCC
erm not at the moment,sorrY!!
dalawapo
the jollibee was squash by the building icon_sad.gif

wow did any of the filipinos think terorism when it happem? icon_confused.gif
Bandcamp
what if i gave you my email, will u send them to me then? or better yet we can trade pics, how does that sound
PuccaCC
QUOTE (dalawapo @ Jul 28 2004, 03:32 PM)
the jollibee was squash by the building icon_sad.gif

wow did any of the filipinos think terorism when it happem? icon_confused.gif

god if filipinos think its terrorism straight away then thats just pure ignorance.read into it i say.

yeah i was gonna say the same thing.all them yummy burgers man.one branch losing profit.oh well.build a bigger jolibee.ang sarap naman!! icon_smile.gif
Ek-ek
QUOTE (dalawapo @ Jul 26 2004, 02:02 PM)
wouldnt it be safer to build buildings out of wood or something since the philippines is situtated in the ring of fire?

or what about architectually designed buildings to sustain earthquakes?

icon_rolleyes.gif Wood?

There is already a lack of wood in the country ! very few forest patches are remaining !

It might be bacause of poor foundations , series of constructions and soil around the area!
poknat
QUOTE (dalawapo @ Jul 26 2004, 01:02 AM)
wouldnt it be safer to build buildings out of wood or something since the philippines is situtated in the ring of fire?

or what about architectually designed buildings to sustain earthquakes?

confused.gif eek.gif Wood? Sure then the termites icon_twisted.gif and bugs sure.gif to destroy them............
BatangDamo
Hmmmmm, When an impressive new building structure is built, they wanna know who's the Architect......


but when the building collapse, they blame the engineers.....


icon_confused.gif
Ek-ek
They should also see the soil samples in which the building stood!

The former building stood near a creek. so the soil there is somewhat loose.
parok_mah
QUOTE (Bandcamp @ Jul 28 2004, 03:09 PM)
your one hot chic puccacc, how bout posting more pics of yourself

haha.. has this something to do with the building? embarassedlaugh.gif
peace out
Forumwalker
QUOTE (Cuong @ Jul 25 2004, 01:03 AM)
QUOTE (kim_kayie @ Jul 25 2004, 01:34 AM)
QUOTE (Cuong @ Jul 24 2004, 09:08 AM)
*I pray for all those that die* "may the heaven gate be open for you to enter"

there are no casualties like parok said... but thanks for your concerns!

These reporter bull$hit alot. I bet there is tones of death and distruction. There has to be......

there are no casualties obviously since the building already "told" them it was going to fall at around 10 am. it fell about 4pm so the area was cordoned off.

QUOTE
wouldnt it be safer to build buildings out of wood or something since the philippines is situtated in the ring of fire?

or what about architectually designed buildings to sustain earthquakes?


wood is not effective. you'd be blown off while you're asleep once there's a typhoon which is most of the time the main cause of calamities. there's termites around too. and take note that RP has more moisture and humidity is wet so wood would break down easily.
kim_kayie
i dont think wood would be a better idea... most of the people here are renovating their houses and change them into concrete materials.
anjing
QUOTE (kim_kayie @ Aug 3 2004, 11:29 AM)
i dont think wood would be a better idea... most of the people here are renovating their houses and change them into concrete materials.

tear proof kasi ang concrete and for fire protection na rin...
Ek-ek
The problem with the owners of the said building is that according to the owner it had no building insurance what so ever!
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2009 Invision Power Services, Inc.