Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Press Freedom Continue to Deteriorate in Malaysia ....
Asia Finest Discussion Forum > Asian Culture > Malaysian Chat > Malaysian Serious Talk
DrGieL3
You can ask Raja Petra how our UMNO State treat him like "criminal" .....
However, thanks to the internet that give us more space for "press freedom" ...

QUOTE
Eritrea comes last, replacing North Korea, while China and Burma still rank near bottom

G8 members, except Russia, recover lost ground

Eritrea has replaced North Korea in last place in an index measuring the level of press freedom in 169 countries throughout the world that is published today by Reporters Without Borders for the sixth year running.

“There is nothing surprising about this,” Reporters Without Borders said. “Even if we are not aware of all the press freedom violations in North Korea and Turkmenistan, which are second and third from last, Eritrea deserves to be at the bottom. The privately-owned press has been banished by the authoritarian President Issaias Afeworki and the few journalists who dare to criticise the regime are thrown in prison. We know that four of them have died in detention and we have every reason to fear that others will suffer the same fate.”

Outside Europe - in which the top 14 countries are located - no region of the world has been spared censorship or violence towards journalists.

Of the 20 countries at the bottom of the index, seven are Asian (Pakistan, Sri Lanka, Laos, Vietnam, China, Burma, and North Korea), five are African (Ethiopia, Equatorial Guinea, Libya, Somalia and Eritrea), four are in the Middle East (Syria, Iraq, Palestinian Territories and Iran), three are former Soviet republics (Belarus, Uzbekistan and Turkmenistan) and one is in the Americas (Cuba).

“We are particularly disturbed by the situation in Burma (164th),” Reporters Without Borders said. “The military junta’s crackdown on demonstrations bodes ill for the future of basic freedoms in this country. Journalists continue to work under the yoke of harsh censorship from which nothing escapes, not even small ads. We also regret that China (163rd) stagnates near the bottom of the index. With less than a year to go to the 2008 Beijing Olympics, the reforms and the releases of imprisoned journalists so often promised by the authorities seem to be a vain hope.”

Military coups hit freedoms


Military coups that were supposed to restore democratic order in Thailand (135th) and Fiji (107th) in fact led to a deterioration in the situation of the news media. The Bangkok-based media continue to be relatively free, but the military prevented the deposed prime minister’s supporters from launching a TV station, and several website editors and bloggers were arrested. In Fiji, there were several weeks of tension between the army and journalists, and a foreign reporter was expelled. Thereafter, the pressure focused on those voicing criticism online.

Pakistan (152nd) continues to get a low ranking. All authority is concentrated in the army, led by Gen. Pervez Musharraf, who seized power in a coup in 1999. The privately-owned TV stations were prevented from working freely and dozens of reporters were beaten and arrested during a crisis precipitated by Musharraf’s dismissal of the supreme court president.

War and peace

War is largely responsible for the low position assigned to some countries. The increase in fighting in Somalia (159th) and Sri Lanka (156th) has made it very hard for journalists to work. Several have been killed and censorship was stepped up as clashes became frequent. The belligerents refuse to recognise journalists’ rights and accuse them of supporting the other side.

In Afghanistan (142nd), the threats initially came from the Taliban and their allies. An Italian reporter’s driver and fixer were beheaded by one of Mullah Omar’s lieutenants, while several radio stations were attacked by armed groups. Weakened by the fighting and corruption, the government showed signs of nervousness. Several journalists were arrested by the intelligence services on trumped-up charges.

As predicted last year, Nepal (137th) has surged more than 20 places in the ranking. The end of the war and the return to democratic rule resulted in a revival of basic freedoms and created new space for the media. But ethnic violence in the south of the country exposed journalists to new dangers.

Unexpected improvements

Cambodia (85th) climbed a few rungs thanks to the government’s decision to decriminalize press offences. No journalist was imprisoned. But some journalists were targeted by death threats, especially when they covered corruption.

Philippines (128th) had fewer murders than in previous years. And President Gloria Arroyo’s associates brought fewer defamation actions against journalists and news media.

G8 members, except Russia, show slight improvement

After falling steadily in the index for the past three years, the G8 members have recovered a few places. France (31st), for example, has climbed six places in the past year. French journalists were spared the violence that affected them at the end of 2005 in a labour conflict in Corsica and during the demonstrations in the city suburbs. But many concerns remain about repeated censorship, searches of news organisations, and a lack of guarantees for the confidentiality of journalists’ sources.

There were slightly fewer press freedom violations in the United States (48th) and blogger Josh Wolf was freed after 224 days in prison. But the detention of Al-Jazeera’s Sudanese cameraman, Sami Al-Haj, since 13 June 2002 at the military base of Guantanamo and the murder of Chauncey Bailey in Oakland in August mean the United States is still unable to join the lead group.

Italy (35th) has also stopped its fall, even if journalists continue to be under threat from mafia groups that prevent them from working in complete safety. Japan (37th) has seen a letup in attacks on the press by militant nationalists, and this has allowed it to recover 14 places.

“These developments are good news,” Reporters Without Borders said. “Perhaps the repeated calls to these democracies to behave in an exemplary manner has finally borne fruit. But we must remain careful and vigilant. Nothing can be taken for granted and we hope this trend will continue or even accentuate near year. We regret all the same that only two G8 members, Canada (18th) and Germany (20th), managed to be among the top 20.”

Russia (144th) is not progressing. Anna Politkovskaya’s murder in October 2006, the failure to punish those responsible for murdering journalists, and the still glaring lack of diversity in the media, especially the broadcast media, weighed heavily in the evaluation of press freedom in Russia.

Government repression no longer ignores bloggers

The Internet is occupying more and more space in the breakdown of press freedom violations. Several countries fell in the ranking this year because of serious, repeated violations of the free flow of online news and information.

In Malaysia (124th), Thailand (135th), Vietnam (162nd) and Egypt (146th), for example, bloggers were arrested and news websites were closed or made inaccessible. “We are concerned about the increase in cases of online censorship,” Reporters Without Borders said. “More and more governments have realised that the Internet can play a key role in the fight for democracy and they are establishing new methods of censoring it. The governments of repressive countries are now targeting bloggers and online journalists as forcefully as journalists in the traditional media.”

At least 64 persons are currently imprisoned worldwide because of what they posted on the Internet. China maintains its leadership in this form of repression, with a total of 50 cyber-dissidents in prison. Eight are being held in Vietnam. A young man known as Kareem Amer was sentenced to four years in prison in Egypt for blog posts criticising the president and Islamist control of the country’s universities.

Reporters Without Borders compiled this index by sending a questionnaire to the 15 freedom of expression organisations throughout the world that are its partners, to its network of 130 correspondents, and to journalists, researchers, jurists and human rights activists. It contained 50 questions about press freedom in their countries. The index covers 169 nations. Other countries were not included because of lack of data.

For more detail: http://www.rsf.org/article.php3?id_article=24023
etano
I have actually stopped reading articles on local news especially political news in our mainstream newspaper. Now, whenever i get hold of my NST, i'll only read the sports, leisure, business and entertainment sections. For local news, i rather go to a few unbiased sites in the internet.







pancaindera
QUOTE(etano @ Oct 17 2007, 07:55 PM) *
I have actually stopped reading articles on local news especially political news in our mainstream newspaper. Now, whenever i get hold of my NST, i'll only read the sports, leisure, business and entertainment sections. For local news, i rather go to a few unbiased sites in the internet.

haha. me too. beerchug.gif the political news is so annoying and stressful to read. thumbsdown.gif
HangPC2
tak macam jiran sebelah kiter bebas sampai tahap menghina negara orang lah.....
Betong
^Hahahaha betul tu...
etano
QUOTE(HangPC2 @ Oct 17 2007, 10:12 AM) *
tak macam jiran sebelah kiter bebas sampai tahap menghina negara orang lah.....


at least they are reporting the reality
HangPC2
QUOTE(etano @ Oct 18 2007, 05:20 AM) *
at least they are reporting the reality



Bukan Realiti tapi melampau

biasalah nak laris surat khabar katakan.... laugh.gif
pancaindera
Jadi apa pula kebaikan menghadkan kebebasan akhbar untuk negara kita?
etano
QUOTE(pancaindera @ Oct 18 2007, 01:35 AM) *
Jadi apa pula kebaikan menghadkan kebebasan akhbar untuk negara kita?


panca, untuk HangPC2, adalah baik untuk "sorok" berita-berita yang benar tetapi kurang baik daripada diketahui umum. Kalau dia melakukan perbuatan yang salah, orang awam tak payah tahu dengan ini barulah dia boleh terus melakukan perbuatan itu. Namanya tak boleh dicemar, nanti habislah semua reputasinya ( kononya adalah tu ) dan silap-silap habis semua. Kalau pasal hal orang lain, tak apa, HangPC2 mahu disiarkan di suratkhabar supaya semua orang tahu dan tambah lagi sana sini untuk jadikan berita sensasi. Itulah HangPC2 kita
HangPC2
aku bukan nak cadangkan berita buruk disekat tapi , masalah bukan nak sekat terus kebebasan media tapi kebanyakan Media meng '' Sensasi '' kan atau dikenali sebagai '' Nasi Tambah '' ini boleh mengeruhkan keadaan....


lihat lah macam keadan sekarang nih....
etano
QUOTE(HangPC2 @ Oct 18 2007, 07:31 AM) *
aku bukan nak cadangkan berita buruk disekat tapi , masalah bukan nak sekat terus kebebasan media tapi kebanyakan Media meng '' Sensasi '' kan atau dikenali sebagai '' Nasi Tambah '' ini boleh mengeruhkan keadaan....
lihat lah macam keadan sekarang nih....


Your comment on " sensasi kan / nasi tambah " is more applicable to entertainment gossips and definitely the local medias do not " sensasi kan " serious news unless the news is really " sensasi ". untuk makluman pada 4/10, PM dalam perhimpunan Gerakan mengesa semua pihak untuk bebas bersuara supaya sebarang masalah boleh diselesaikan " . Pada 10/10, Menteri Penerangan ( Zainuddin ) mengumpulkan ketua "editor" media tempatan dan beritahu mereka kebebasan bersuara itu HANYA untuk parti komponen kerajaan dan bukan pihak media.

Dari sini, cuba renungkan mengapakan menteri berbuat demikian. Kesimpulan saya, rakyat tidak patut tahu perkara yang kurang baik mengenai kerajaan. Pihak media cuma dibenar siarkan berita "sugar coated".
caramel
It's really unfair to us, considering that we are citizens of the country. Many issues are left unresolved and our money are being spent recklessly. I am quite upset with how our government is currently running. Inefficient, lack accountability and respect.

I just hope that there would be a better check and balance for the next term (that is considering if they win it anyway).
caramel
QUOTE
Saturday October 20, 2007

RSF press freedom rating not valid, says Zam

KUALA LUMPUR: Malaysians and other Asians should ignore the press freedom ratings made by the Paris-based Reporters Without Borders (RSF) as the body is not a judge on local values, Information Minister Datuk Seri Zainuddin Maidin said yesterday.

He said the ratings were based on Western values of press freedom, which were mainly driven by the market and money.

A recent index announcement by RSF saw Malaysia’s ratings falling to 124th spot this year from 92nd in 2006 while Singapore took 141st spot from 146th previously.

Zainuddin said in a statement that he lauded Singapore’s former prime minister Lee Kuan Yew for fighting the Western values of press freedom and winning against London’s Financial Times (FT) newspaper recently.

On Wednesday, FT apologised to Lee and other members of his family and agreed to pay damages for false allegations contained in an article which appeared in the FT's Sept 29 issue.

Zainuddin said: “For me, the only language understood by the Western media is when their pockets are hit.”

By taking legal action and winning the case, he said, Lee had proven to the world that the Western media valued money more than press freedom.

Zainuddin said Malaysians and Asians should not be worried about the drop in rankings of press freedom in Malaysia as it did not reflect the truth of press freedom in the country.

The minister said that Lee, in a keynote address to the International Bar Association Annual Conference in Singapore on Oct 14, said the people of Singapore had wide access to information and they could blog and do anything they liked, but stressed that issues of race, language and religion had to be handled sensitively. – Bernama


embarassedlaugh.gif
Majapahitans
QUOTE(HangPC2 @ Oct 17 2007, 10:12 AM) *
tak macam jiran sebelah kiter bebas sampai tahap menghina negara orang lah.....



beerchug.gif Hidup Kemerdekaan Pers...!

Anda merasa dizalimi oleh pers (media)...?

1. Gunakan hak jawab, counter with your version/your side of story.
If that not enough....
2. Sue them la....! kiss.gif

However I still believe press must be free to report the fact,
and bestowed the right to criticize and questioned the government dubious policy.

Btw I work for your "jiran sebelah" media.... biggthumpup.gif

A Malaysian thinker interviewed by Indonesian media regarding on 50th years of Malaysian Independence says:
"If Malaysian glorious development has some defect, or something is missing, then press freedom and social justice would be the one."
Means: state has overwhelmingly control the media and also discrimination issues.
etano
QUOTE(caramel @ Oct 21 2007, 06:00 AM) *
embarassedlaugh.gif


When the rating does not favour Malaysia, then it is not reliable but when the rating favours Malaysia then it is a very reliable. This is typical of Malaysia
pepoluan
QUOTE(etano @ Oct 21 2007, 09:08 PM) *
When the rating does not favour Malaysia, then it is not reliable but when the rating favours Malaysia then it is a very reliable. This is typical of Malaysia


I was going to say that, but you stole the words right out of my mouth biggrin.gif

Oh, and congratulations to Indonesia, who now ranked 100th with a score of 30,50 icon_smile.gif

Granted, we (Indonesia) got only one upward arrow, but IMO that's a lot better than the double downward arrows that Malaysia got...
Protoculture
QUOTE
I was going to say that, but you stole the words right out of my mouth

Oh, and congratulations to Indonesia, who now ranked 100th with a score of 30,50

Granted, we (Indonesia) got only one upward arrow, but IMO that's a lot better than the double downward arrows that Malaysia got...


But, we still have many more upwardly mobile arrows compared than you .... you're saying ...
destoyasoy
>__<
etano
QUOTE(pepoluan @ Oct 26 2007, 05:06 PM) *
I was going to say that, but you stole the words right out of my mouth biggrin.gif

Oh, and congratulations to Indonesia, who now ranked 100th with a score of 30,50 icon_smile.gif

Granted, we (Indonesia) got only one upward arrow, but IMO that's a lot better than the double downward arrows that Malaysia got...


I see no relevance at all with your comparison. I am only watching the ranking of malaysia, indonesia's is non of my concern at all
Jaimu-Jaimu
Freedom of the press is over-rated.
It's just a displacement of power where as opposed to regimes having it, the press acquires it.
mahatir
FYI,

For malaysian who can't read such news in their country:

QUOTE
Anwar Ibrahim: Pers Malaysia Dikontrol Agar Jelekkan Indonesia

Jakarta - Mantan Wakil PM Malaysia Anwar Ibrahim membantah rakyat Malaysia berniat jahat terhadap warga negara Indonesia di Malaysia. Rakyat Malaysia saat ini hanyalah korban dari pers Malaysia yang dikontrol ketat oleh pemerintah.

"Informasi dibendung. Yang didapat, Indonesia cemburu karena ekonomi Malaysia lebih baik. Yang disebut dari Indonesia hanya case jenayah, pembunuhan," kata Anwar dalam jumpa pers usai bertemu pimpinan DPD di Gedung DPD, Senayan, Jakarta, Jumat (16/11/2007).

Berita reformasi di Indonesia pun diputar balik oleh pers Malaysia. "Mereka lihat reformasi di Indonesia ini (seperti), perang, bakar!," kata Anwar.

Malaysia disebut Anwar berada dalam era otoritarian. Pers dikungkung. Pemilu curang, dikontrol partai terbesar, UMNO. Korupsi diamini oleh pemerintahan PM Abdullah Badawi.

"Komisi pemilihan raya yang seharusnya bebas menjadi alatnya UMNO. Banyak pengundi (pemilih-red) hantu," kata Anwar.

Pernah ada penyelidikan di suatu kampung, ditemukan puluhan kartu pemilih orang yang sudah berusia 100 tahun lebih. Secara nasional, pemilih hantu seperti itu bisa mencapai ratusan ribu orang.

"Itulah (tujuan) aksi 10 November lalu," kata Anwar. "Yang kita minta hanya satu saja, jamin pemilihan raya yang bebas. Kita tidak minta kebebasan pers," imbuhnya.

"Kebebasan pers seperti di Indonesia bagi Abdullah Badawi terlalu radikal," pungkas Anwar yang baru saja memiliki cucu berusia 2 bulan dari anaknya, Nurul Izzah.


source: http://www.detiknews.com/index.php/detik.r...3702/idkanal/10
swingdoctor
It doesn't matter the comparison between Indonesia and Malaysia, the rating suggests that both countries still have a way to go. Having said that,my country Australia who in the past has taken the moral high ground, although we're pretty good we could be alot better considering yhe stance we have taken.



swingdoctor
I ment to add this last night but was too tired.

I agree with Jaimu-Jaimu that freedom of the press usually just means the transfering of power from the government to the press. I disagree though that its over-rated. I think there must be accountability by the governmet and most people remain oblivious to the goings on of the government and rely on the press to inform them. Usually without freedom of the press comes corruption and persecution and I think in a successful democracy, freedom of the press is very important. But like everything else in the world, nothing is ever absolute, therefore with freedom of the press should also come an independent judiciary. I think an independent judiciary system and independent press are paramount to a fair and successful society. I admit though that some journalists do abuse the power given to them but I think this is a price that has to be paid. Besides as a society matures, they tend to pick out what is good journalism and what is not.
firdausj
Another joke from Malaysian Information Minister ....

QUOTE
Malaysian information minister criticized the Indonesian press
Prodita Sabarini, The Jakarta Post, Denpasar

The Malaysian information minister criticized the Indonesian press for being too open, saying the media here is insensitive to Malaysian politics.

Dato' Seri Zainudin said the Indonesian media was "too excited" by the freedoms it had been granted since the downfall of the New Order regime in 1998.

Speaking to journalists after a meeting with Malaysian students studying in Bali at the Wina Holliday Inn in Kuta, the minister criticized the Indonesian media for providing air time to Malaysian opposition leader and former deputy prime minister Anwar Ibrahim.

In October, Anwar was interviewed on Metro TV's talk show Kick Andy. In the interview, Anwar spoke candidly about corruption and the suppression of the press in Malaysia, topics that are rarely covered by the mainstream media there.

"We view this as insensitive. We would never provide space for the opposition of Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono or someone anti-Indonesian in the Malaysian media," Zainudin said.

He asked the media in both countries to refrain from reporting on issues that could provoke negative feelings.

"The media should emphasize the positive and seek good things to report," he said. "After all, we want to create a good relationship between the two countries."

Indonesia has been ranked 100th out of 169 countries in the Reporters Without Borders' 2007 Press Freedom Index, while Malaysia ranked 124th, dropping 32 places from last year. It was Malaysia's lowest position in its media history.

In Southeast Asia, Cambodia topped the list (ranked 85th in the world), followed by Timor Leste (94th).

Indonesia's press freedom boomed after the downfall of Soeharto in 1998 and the closure of the Information Ministry, an institution that controlled the media in Indonesia, in 1999 by the then president Abdurrahman Wahid, and the passing of the 1999 Press Law, guaranteeing press freedom in Indonesia.

Zainudin said Indonesia was facing the "euphoria of freedom after being suppressed".

He added that in Malaysia the media has never been suppressed, while suggesting that Malaysia has a "guided" freedom.

Most Malaysian newspapers and electronic media outlets are controlled by the government or political parties in the ruling coalition. They also operate with a government license, which must be renewed annually. Internet news sites do not have these restrictions.

Contacted by telephone in Jakarta, chairman of the Indonesian Press Council Ichlasul Amal said Indonesian press freedom was in line with the spirit of reform and democracy and that the Malaysian media was the one that should be more open.

"There is a lot of information that the Malaysian public needs to know, but which is inaccessible. The news there has become homogeneous," he said.

Ichlasul said that in Indonesia, the biggest threat to press freedom was within journalists themselves. "A lack of professionalism and work ethics will jeopardize press freedom here. If journalists do not improve themselves, they will lose their credibility and the public's trust in them."
coolooc
I would not read Utusan Malaysia or Berita Harian, despite being paid to read it!

I cannot imagine people actually buying those papers to read it!

That is why Mahathir said the bloggers are really the last remaining hope of the nation!

Don't blame Utusan Malaysia la, it is owned by Umno, the party with low standard morons and extremists.

Utusan Malaysia, the Star, New Strait Times etc, are just a few shameless newspapers that often cover up the scandals of BN government and to make oppositions look bad.
ruyom
If you turn on BBC, there are fair and equal coverage on the UK opposition parties.

So is NHK (Japan), so is KBS (Korea), so is CNN (America), so is CBC (Canada), so is ABC (Australia).

Even in our neighboring Thailand, their TV coverage is fair for both ruling and opposition parties!

Only in this Umno hijacked country that you find most lop-sided idiotic coverage on Umno and its running dog partners!
Protoculture
Press freedom .... uhh is there any in MY?

Seriously though, for all fairness, I still read local papers, most notably the STAR, although still a little bit biased but its content tend to be good (especially the classifieds section!)

For my anti-BN phase, the PAS' Harakah served up all things spicy politically (justified or not).

Not that media controlled by Govt. is a good thing, but we still need to rein our media. Lest to say, somebody with to many time in their hand start some malicious reportings that could stir racial or religious tensions.

Frankly though, I'm not happy with the state of press freedom in MY. Hope Pak Lah rectify that, but given his Govt. rhetorics against anti-Govt. bloggers, I fear press freedom is only a wishful thinking.
swingdoctor
Its difficult to be critical of The Star because a while ago its printing licence was suspended by the govnt for publishing articles that were less then complimentary to the govnt. This is the problem with the Malaysian govnt, any media that is less then complimentary let alone critical gets shut down.
Protoculture
QUOTE
This is the problem with the Malaysian govnt, any media that is less then complimentary let alone critical gets shut down.


There's always the new media alternative around, such as the INTERNET.

Thank God for that ....
swingdoctor
QUOTE(Protoculture @ Feb 27 2008, 04:37 AM) *
There's always the new media alternative around, such as the INTERNET.

Thank God for that ....

I agree, and the internet is more difficult to police but evenso, the Malaysian govnt is still trying. Remember the bloggers they arrested?
Protoculture
QUOTE
Remember the bloggers they arrested?


Yeah, but they cannot find enough loophole to charge the Bloggers. Apart from 'Akta Hasutan', nothing else.

swingdoctor
QUOTE(Protoculture @ Feb 28 2008, 10:21 PM) *
Yeah, but they cannot find enough loophole to charge the Bloggers. Apart from 'Akta Hasutan', nothing else.

Whats happened to them do you know?
pancaindera
Watching prime time news in RTM or TV3 makes me feel like im in another country, like China or North Korea. The only publicity they give the opposition are bad publisities. They try to dig out even the smallest matter and blow it up as if it were a massive issue. I hope the general public realise this biasness and just shove aside like a joke, or dont watch it at all.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.