Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: (maybe disturbing)Fried Dogs, Rats, and Bats
Asia Finest Discussion Forum > Asian Culture > Indonesian Chat
purnomor



Dogs are a popular dish in North Sulawesi, generally served as a barbecue


Bats are fried, then served with rice


Cow feet are served as a soup


Another exotic dish from North Sulawesi is fried rat


Python snakes are made into skewered meat (sate) or eaten with rice
Nusantara
In my place dog as a friend when you go hunting for wild boar. we malay from sumatra never eat dog.
Ethnic Batak Toba from North Sumatra also very famous eating dog. they make meat kind a curry from dog they call it saksang and eat it with rice fermentation drink called tuak.
Both these guy North Sulawesi and Batak Toba practice Cristian.
Ek-ek
There are also foods like that in the Philippines!
Nusantara
Is it acceptable mostly by philipines or merely specific ehnics?
Ek-ek
Most Filipinos eat dogs especially those from the Northern Philippines.

Bats are also fried and eaten .
mamapeace
omg, looks like that those bads were screaming before they got killed.
purnomor
QUOTE (Nusantara @ Aug 6 2004, 03:37 AM)
Ethnic Batak Toba from North Sumatra also very famous eating dog. they make meat kind a curry from dog they call it saksang and eat it with rice fermentation drink called tuak.

Yeah i remember when i was a lil kid batak construction workers renovating neighbors house kidnap my dog for one of their nighttime BBQ

boy those construction workers really broke my heart like i cried for days afterwards T_T
my poor dog bawling.gif bawling.gif bawling.gif bawling.gif bawling.gif bawling.gif

i remember his name was Alf after the space dog in an american tv comedy playin on tvri at that time icon_sad.gif
purnomor
QUOTE (Ek-ek @ Aug 6 2004, 04:24 AM)
There are also foods like that in the Philippines!

Yeah i think manado/minahasa people of north sulawesi got lots of similarities with filipinos. it's just one hour by plane from manado to davao in mindanao. from indonesian island of miangas (las palmas) one can see the mountains of mindanao in the horizon.
btw, are filipinos allowed to eat rat as well?
EmSkittles19
wow those pics are kinda gruesome but that's no problem because if ya gotta survive, ya gotta survive. i mean, here you have meat that doesn't need to graze around and produce 10,000 tons of methane fart a year and smell like crap noo no. hehe darn them tasty cows...
kim_kayie
well i hope they will stop it....
sorry but not only for the dogs... but some of those animals are already endangered....
Rocky Cuong V
............... sure.gif this thread is making me sick.
Nusantara
QUOTE (EmSkittles19 @ Aug 6 2004, 09:59 AM)
wow those pics are kinda gruesome but that's no problem because if ya gotta survive, ya gotta survive.

the Batak Toba and North Sulawesi ethnic people eating dog there is nothing to do with survival. They sell it openly in their eating house they call it lapo tuak. Indeed the price of a plate of dog meat more expensive than chicken. Some high profile person of batak happily still eat it.

well, eventhough most indoensian does not eat dog but this is part of habitual batak toba and north sulawesi habitual and as part of Indonesian as bigger frame. I am not quiet sure what's the stories behind this.

like or dislike got to live with it.

The annoying things is I kept losing my dog if there is batak live near by our place. The big problem is some times the one who stole my dog is not the batak himself, it could be somebody else and sell it to batak.

Do you guys think Indonesian should ban this habitual? remember this is not about survival? the price of a plate of dog meat more expensive than full plate of chicken?
Andromeda
I don't know whether it's true.. but it is said that black dog with black tongue is highly priced.

My friend's dog was kidnapped because it fit these charateristics.
EmSkittles19
there should be a law where you can not kidnap someone elses doggy! you should put on the dog a bomb collar so that anyone try to take it out to cooking him they blow up because if the doggy gonna die and go into someone stomach then you can not give them any satisfaction of their wrong doing!!
Nusantara
yeah man i agree with you, also mostly dog belong to somebody else. Very rare now to see dog roaming around freely without somebody claim belong to it.
I think indonesia goverment should ban this habitual unless Batak and Minahasa ethnic people can produce dog farming just special for dog meat to consume.
BishoujoHunter
eating dogs has been banned in the philippines

some people eat rats on farms in the philippines
rasibiduk
I heard Korean are a big dog eaters too.
purnomor
QUOTE (Nusantara @ Aug 7 2004, 02:43 AM)
I think indonesia goverment should ban this habitual unless Batak and Minahasa ethnic people can produce dog farming just special for dog meat to consume.

That's a great idea! Let there be no more dog-kidnapping for the sake of traditional food..
beerchug.gif
Nusantara
Yes, that's fair solution, They still can preserve their habitual if we can not say this as culture. beerchug.gif
Only perhaps animal loving society won't want to be understood about this Batak and Minahasa habitual.
Garuda
I thought "saksang" was a traditional batak meal made with pork or wild pork... I'm half batak and half sunda... and dog eating is a very rare habit. I see a lot of abandonned dogs in indonesian streets even though it's not a reason to eat them. I don't think a law against dog eating is necessary overall there are a lot of more important problems in Indonesia... However, i think there is a law against dog stealings no ?? icon_wink.gif
Anyway guys, i feel sorry for your dogs, because i also have one, and i don't want to see him in a BBQ !!! sure.gif
Nusantara
Hey welcome Garuda! how's your vacation? are you back in Paris now?
So you eat dog embarassedlaugh.gif
babieamy012
ive tried dog but not rat...i heard it is quite good...i dont know about bats. i think these meats are considered a delicacy in most of the places where they are eaten? well, in korea dog meat is one of those specialty items...the pictures above are pretty graphic and unappetizing though...i think just cuz they are whole so it reminds me of a carcass rather than food...probably good in soup or at least cut up.
Nusantara
try eating dog meat beyond my curiousity, I have so much dog as my pet since i was very small kid beside well...that is odd. What the good things of dog meat?
PervertBurger
Damn that dog meat looks hella good.
Rocky Cuong V
lolz. Dogs, rat and bats. Some food..... sure.gif Disgusting
Iron Malayan
Turtles are also eaten by some ethnic groups.
poknat
QUOTE (BishoujoHunter @ Aug 7 2004, 03:17 AM)
eating dogs has been banned in the philippines

some people eat rats on farms in the philippines

confused.gif Yes, But there were still people who ate dogs.

As for rats ,yes there were a lot of provinces in the Philippines who practice eating rtas but not the common rats it is field mice that they ate
purnomor



Shark is a very popular dish in Indonesian province of Aceh, where one whole shark costs around Rp 100,000 (US$ 10.93)
Iron Malayan
I always order shark's fin soup whenever I dine in a Chinese restaurant.Yummyy....but I don't think it's a good idea to eat the meat. I heard the mercury content is very high.
Nusantara
In Riau on the traditional fishing market I always find people selling shark. Yet shark is not populer dish, I have test the meat is kind a rough. And the price of shark is cheaper than red snapper.
Fil-Am
QUOTE (Ek-ek @ Aug 6 2004, 05:03 AM)
Most Filipinos eat dogs especially those from the Northern Philippines.

Bats are also fried and eaten .

Ek-Ek not most, I don't eat dog. And neither does anyone in my family, Eww.
purnomor

One rather exotic Indonesian food I like is stewed beef tongue


The best exotic food is the beef brain curry (gulai otak), a Minangkabau dish biggthumpup.gif munch.gif munch.gif
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2010 Invision Power Services, Inc.