fujisan_8
Aug 6 2004, 10:02 PM
Are confucious values/beliefs/customs still prevalient in China? It seems to me that it's ironic that his ideals were of a highly structured society with an emphasis on education and hierachial structures, yet when you look at China:
- everything is kind of unstructured (all over the place, just look at the roads as a prime exaple).
- it's still relatively uneducated, i mean for university graduates.
- it's still hierachial BUT kind of not.
- OK, women arent treated like men in China, but it's worse in Japan and South Korea, confucious values oppress women.
Looking at Japan and South Korea heck, even North Korea I reckon they would be more of a Confucious country than China is or ever was.
caolucai
Aug 6 2004, 10:07 PM
yah..it's sad, Mao did a pretty good job of ridding mainland China of Confucian values during the Cultural Revolution
fujisan_8
Aug 6 2004, 10:10 PM
| QUOTE (caolucai @ Aug 6 2004, 11:07 PM) |
yah..it's sad, Mao did a pretty good job of ridding mainland China of Confucian values during the Cultural Revolution |
Yeah, he tried to "re create" his own history.
Confucian values I reckon these days are better reflected in the Japan and Korea's societies than any Chinese territory - the hard working, humble type values.
Two things I have to note:
- There has been some suggestions that Korea is the most Confucious state in the world.
- Some claims have been made that Confucious was actually Korean and not Han Chinese (he was from Shandong).
Confucian values are and will always exist in Chinese society. right now, it just exists in some pseudo capitalist/socialist state
福州市长
Aug 6 2004, 10:14 PM
無聊
fujisan_8
Aug 6 2004, 10:15 PM
Hahhaha wu liao?
What do you consider worthwhile then? sheesh.
MING-LOYALIST
Aug 6 2004, 10:16 PM
| QUOTE (fujisan_8 @ Aug 6 2004, 11:10 PM) |
| QUOTE (caolucai @ Aug 6 2004, 11:07 PM) | yah..it's sad, Mao did a pretty good job of ridding mainland China of Confucian values during the Cultural Revolution |
Yeah, he tried to "re create" his own history.
Confucian values I reckon these days are better reflected in the Japan and Korea's societies than any Chinese territory - the hard working, humble type values.
Two things I have to note:
- There has been some suggestions that Korea is the most Confucious state in the world.
- Some claims have been made that Confucious was actually Korean and not Han Chinese (he was from Shandong).
|
First of all you don't know much about CCP history nor do you understand China in the Mao-era.
Chinese wanted to get rid of alot of Confucian values cause some were just too outdated and is simply opressive.
Also if you think Japan or Korea are ideal Confucian societies then you are just delusional.
福州市长
Aug 6 2004, 10:18 PM
| QUOTE (fujisan_8 @ Aug 6 2004, 11:15 PM) |
Hahhaha wu liao?
What do you consider worthwhile then? sheesh. |
因為你問的東西太復紮了
caolucai
Aug 6 2004, 10:19 PM
| QUOTE (fujisan_8 @ Aug 6 2004, 11:10 PM) |
| QUOTE (caolucai @ Aug 6 2004, 11:07 PM) | yah..it's sad, Mao did a pretty good job of ridding mainland China of Confucian values during the Cultural Revolution |
Yeah, he tried to "re create" his own history.
Confucian values I reckon these days are better reflected in the Japan and Korea's societies than any Chinese territory - the hard working, humble type values.
Two things I have to note:
- There has been some suggestions that Korea is the most Confucious state in the world.
- Some claims have been made that Confucious was actually Korean and not Han Chinese (he was from Shandong).
|
yeah, but koreans abuse Confcuius's teachings
they're really into that whole respect the elder thing, older kids get away w/ beating up younger kids; even one grade level can make a whole lot of difference
example: chinese, taiwanese, korean (oldest) working on homework; taiwanese and korean debating over correct answers, taiwanese says, "fine, i'll put my answer, and you can stick to yours." 30min later...korean turns around to taiwanese, "you can't talk to me like that!! in korea, we respect our elders...."
have any of you read The Memoirs of Lady Hyegyong?? it talks about korean court life and how they totally misinterpreted Confucian values...
fujisan_8
Aug 6 2004, 10:19 PM
| QUOTE (福州市长 @ Aug 6 2004, 11:18 PM) |
| QUOTE (fujisan_8 @ Aug 6 2004, 11:15 PM) | Hahhaha wu liao?
What do you consider worthwhile then? sheesh. |
因為你問的東西太復紮了
|
ahhaha too complex? maybe for you...
Nam Quoc Son Ha
Aug 6 2004, 10:23 PM
| QUOTE (caolucai @ Aug 6 2004, 11:19 PM) |
| QUOTE (fujisan_8 @ Aug 6 2004, 11:10 PM) | | QUOTE (caolucai @ Aug 6 2004, 11:07 PM) | yah..it's sad, Mao did a pretty good job of ridding mainland China of Confucian values during the Cultural Revolution |
Yeah, he tried to "re create" his own history.
Confucian values I reckon these days are better reflected in the Japan and Korea's societies than any Chinese territory - the hard working, humble type values.
Two things I have to note:
- There has been some suggestions that Korea is the most Confucious state in the world.
- Some claims have been made that Confucious was actually Korean and not Han Chinese (he was from Shandong).
|
yeah, but koreans abuse Confcuius's teachings they're really into that whole respect the elder thing, older kids get away w/ beating up younger kids; even one grade level can make a whole lot of difference example: chinese, taiwanese, korean (oldest) working on homework; taiwanese and korean debating over correct answers, taiwanese says, "fine, i'll put my answer, and you can stick to yours." 30min later...korean turns around to taiwanese, "you can't talk to me like that!! in korea, we respect our elders...." have any of you read The Memoirs of Lady Hyegyong?? it talks about korean court life and how they totally misinterpreted Confucian values... |
Yup the Koreans definitely are abusing Confucian values. If you watch Korean dramas, bosses can often beat their workers senseless and the workers wouldn't even complain one bit.
Those Koreans brought along their tradition to Vietnam and abuses young Vietnamese girls working in their factories.
LoveMakesYouFat
Aug 6 2004, 10:24 PM
| QUOTE |
| example: chinese, taiwanese, korean (oldest) working on homework; taiwanese and korean debating over correct answers, taiwanese says, "fine, i'll put my answer, and you can stick to yours." 30min later...korean turns around to taiwanese, "you can't talk to me like that!! in korea, we respect our elders...." |

You serious? That's fricken overdoing it.
MING-LOYALIST
Aug 6 2004, 10:25 PM
| QUOTE (caolucai @ Aug 6 2004, 11:19 PM) |
| QUOTE (fujisan_8 @ Aug 6 2004, 11:10 PM) | | QUOTE (caolucai @ Aug 6 2004, 11:07 PM) | | |
|
yeah, but koreans abuse Confcuius's teachings they're really into that whole respect the elder thing, older kids get away w/ beating up younger kids; even one grade level can make a whole lot of difference example: chinese, taiwanese, korean (oldest) working on homework; taiwanese and korean debating over correct answers, taiwanese says, "fine, i'll put my answer, and you can stick to yours." 30min later...korean turns around to taiwanese, "you can't talk to me like that!! in korea, we respect our elders...." have any of you read The Memoirs of Lady Hyegyong?? it talks about korean court life and how they totally misinterpreted Confucian values... |
Exactly!!!
The only time did any society almost attianed the ideal Confucian society was the Great TANG dynasty of China and maybe a short period during Zhou dynasty but all the rest were perverted versions of Confucuis used by Governments to exploit people.
fujisan_8
Aug 6 2004, 10:26 PM
When you think about it, that older is wiser or knows best is a total load of bull$hit.
This is why it leads into problems such as comparisions amongst asians.
Nam Quoc Son Ha
Aug 6 2004, 10:28 PM
OK, what are the basic Confucian principles?
福州市长
Aug 6 2004, 10:28 PM
| QUOTE (fujisan_8 @ Aug 6 2004, 11:19 PM) |
| QUOTE (福州市长 @ Aug 6 2004, 11:18 PM) | | QUOTE (fujisan_8 @ Aug 6 2004, 11:15 PM) | Hahhaha wu liao?
What do you consider worthwhile then? sheesh. |
因為你問的東西太復紮了
|
ahhaha too complex? maybe for you...
|
it is too complex because there's no one true answer to it..
when thing pass for thousands of year..they always tend to losing it's exact value
fujisan_8
Aug 6 2004, 10:29 PM
| QUOTE (Nam Quoc Son Ha @ Aug 6 2004, 11:28 PM) |
| OK, what are the basic Confucian principles? |
Have sex and lots of it...hahaha whopps, those are toaist beliefs...
umm i don;t know.
福州市长
Aug 6 2004, 10:31 PM
since u don't know..don't even mention it
Nam Quoc Son Ha
Aug 6 2004, 10:32 PM
| QUOTE (fujisan_8 @ Aug 6 2004, 11:29 PM) |
| QUOTE (Nam Quoc Son Ha @ Aug 6 2004, 11:28 PM) | | OK, what are the basic Confucian principles? |
Have sex and lots of it...hahaha whopps, those are toaist beliefs...
umm i don;t know.
|
Woah really? Taoism is my fav religion now. Muahahaa
Someone should clarify the basic Confucian values first before we discuss this issue.
福州市长
Aug 6 2004, 10:32 PM
don't listen to him la..
my dad was taoist..he never mention that kinda stuff
fujisan_8
Aug 6 2004, 10:33 PM
| QUOTE (福州市长 @ Aug 6 2004, 11:32 PM) |
don't listen to him la.. my dad is taoist..he never mention that kinda stuff |
www.google.com
look up taoist sex
福州市长
Aug 6 2004, 10:36 PM
having sex..u will have more healthy bodyy the ying yang thing...
on one thing.. why south korea use taoism simple as their country flag??
caolucai
Aug 6 2004, 10:42 PM
The flag, called "Tae Kuk," symbolizes the thought, philosophy, and mysticism of the Far East.
The circle in the center, red upper half and blue lower half, represents absolute, or the essential unity of all being. The Yang (positive) and the Yin (negative) divisions within the circle represent duality. Examples of duality are heaven and hell, fire and water, life and death, good and evil, or night and day
The four trigrams also indicate the duality of opposites and balances. In the upper left trigram, three unbroken lines symbolize Heaven; opposite them in the lower right, three broken lines represent Earth. In the upper right trigram, two broken lines separated by an unbroken line is the symbol of Fire; opposite them is water, symbolized by two unbroken lines separated by a broken line.
Symbolic of the nation is the white background (the land), the circle (people), and the four trigrams (the government). All three make up the essential elements of the nation.
韓國人好奇怪...
Nam Quoc Son Ha
Aug 6 2004, 10:47 PM
Yeah that's smart. The South Korean flag is awesome, not stupid dumb@ss like the Vietnamese and Chinese ones.
福州市长
Aug 6 2004, 10:58 PM
but they took it from chinese religion...
LoveMakesYouFat
Aug 6 2004, 10:59 PM
| QUOTE (福州市长 @ Aug 6 2004, 11:58 PM) |
| but they took it from chinese religion... |
Doesn't change the fact that it's better and has meaning. There are very many facets for meaning, it's just the S. Koreans were smart and used it as a flag.
MING-LOYALIST
Aug 6 2004, 11:01 PM
| QUOTE (Nam Quoc Son Ha @ Aug 6 2004, 11:47 PM) |
| Yeah that's smart. The South Korean flag is awesome, not stupid dumb@ss like the Vietnamese and Chinese ones. |
Shut up B!tch, I want my TANG dynasty back!!!!!!!
LoveMakesYouFat
Aug 6 2004, 11:03 PM
| QUOTE (MING-LOYALIST @ Aug 7 2004, 12:01 AM) |
| QUOTE (Nam Quoc Son Ha @ Aug 6 2004, 11:47 PM) | | Yeah that's smart. The South Korean flag is awesome, not stupid dumb@ss like the Vietnamese and Chinese ones. |
Shut up B!tch, I want my TANG dynasty back!!!!!!!
|
What's with you and the Tang dynasty? Your name makes you a Ming loyalist.

Switching dynasties now?
caolucai
Aug 6 2004, 11:04 PM
| QUOTE (LoveMakesYouFat @ Aug 7 2004, 12:03 AM) |
| QUOTE (MING-LOYALIST @ Aug 7 2004, 12:01 AM) | | QUOTE (Nam Quoc Son Ha @ Aug 6 2004, 11:47 PM) | | Yeah that's smart. The South Korean flag is awesome, not stupid dumb@ss like the Vietnamese and Chinese ones. |
Shut up B!tch, I want my TANG dynasty back!!!!!!!
|
What's with you and the Tang dynasty? Your name makes you a Ming loyalist.  Switching dynasties now? |
i guess it's cuz it was during the Tang Dynasty when Chinese religions/language/culture found their way to Korea and Japan.

another good dynasty to get back would be the Yuan Dynasty; only if it lasted longer, then we wouldn't have that many white people picking on us today
LoveMakesYouFat
Aug 6 2004, 11:52 PM
| QUOTE (caolucai @ Aug 7 2004, 12:04 AM) |
| QUOTE (LoveMakesYouFat @ Aug 7 2004, 12:03 AM) | | QUOTE (MING-LOYALIST @ Aug 7 2004, 12:01 AM) | | QUOTE (Nam Quoc Son Ha @ Aug 6 2004, 11:47 PM) | | Yeah that's smart. The South Korean flag is awesome, not stupid dumb@ss like the Vietnamese and Chinese ones. |
Shut up B!tch, I want my TANG dynasty back!!!!!!!
|
What's with you and the Tang dynasty? Your name makes you a Ming loyalist.  Switching dynasties now? |
i guess it's cuz it was during the Tang Dynasty when Chinese religions/language/culture found their way to Korea and Japan.  another good dynasty to get back would be the Yuan Dynasty; only if it lasted longer, then we wouldn't have that many white people picking on us today |
Why wouldn't white people pick on you if the Yuan Dynasty lasted longer?

Not really sure if i should guess or not. Mongols were tall, no? Hahaha
caolucai
Aug 6 2004, 11:56 PM
| QUOTE (LoveMakesYouFat @ Aug 7 2004, 12:52 AM) |
| QUOTE (caolucai @ Aug 7 2004, 12:04 AM) | | QUOTE (LoveMakesYouFat @ Aug 7 2004, 12:03 AM) | | QUOTE (MING-LOYALIST @ Aug 7 2004, 12:01 AM) | | QUOTE (Nam Quoc Son Ha @ Aug 6 2004, 11:47 PM) | | Yeah that's smart. The South Korean flag is awesome, not stupid dumb@ss like the Vietnamese and Chinese ones. |
Shut up B!tch, I want my TANG dynasty back!!!!!!!
|
What's with you and the Tang dynasty? Your name makes you a Ming loyalist.  Switching dynasties now? |
i guess it's cuz it was during the Tang Dynasty when Chinese religions/language/culture found their way to Korea and Japan.  another good dynasty to get back would be the Yuan Dynasty; only if it lasted longer, then we wouldn't have that many white people picking on us today |
Why wouldn't white people pick on you if the Yuan Dynasty lasted longer?  Not really sure if i should guess or not. Mongols were tall, no? Hahaha |
cuz the mongols conquered the entire middle east, if it lasted longer, they could have invaded all the way to western europe; enslave caucasians...j/k

, and change the course of history~
LoveMakesYouFat
Aug 7 2004, 12:01 AM
Ohh, that's why. They originally could've conquered all of Europe, but the Khan died, so they retreated back to Mongolia to decide a new Khan. They never went back.

Let's just say the mongols knew back then Europe wasn't worth all the men needed to fight it, they focused on China from then on i think. And after China they tried to conquer Vietnam, they never really went back to Europe (i'm pretty sure).
caolucai
Aug 7 2004, 12:02 AM
| QUOTE (LoveMakesYouFat @ Aug 7 2004, 01:01 AM) |
Ohh, that's why. They originally could've conquered all of Europe, but the Khan died, so they retreated back to Mongolia to decide a new Khan. They never went back. Let's just say the mongols knew back then Europe wasn't worth all the men needed to fight it, they focused on China from then on i think. And after China they tried to conquer Vietnam, they never really went back to Europe (i'm pretty sure). |
yeah, too bad
276
Aug 13 2004, 05:07 PM
Confucianism is prevalent in Korea, but I have to say that it's also holding the country back. I think Korea is very backwards because of its predominant Confucianist mentality. Some examples are its repression of women, stress on order stymieing creativity, lack of individuality. It's only recently shedding its shackles in becoming more westernized.
I've recently been reading Lao Tzu, and find his philosophy and writings fascinating. Can anyone tell me more about him?
ZurichGrrl
Aug 13 2004, 08:00 PM
| QUOTE (276 @ Aug 13 2004, 06:07 PM) |
Confucianism is prevalent in Korea, but I have to say that it's also holding the country back. I think Korea is very backwards because of its predominant Confucianist mentality. Some examples are its repression of women, stress on order stymieing creativity, lack of individuality. It's only recently shedding its shackles in becoming more westernized.
I've recently been reading Lao Tzu, and find his philosophy and writings fascinating. Can anyone tell me more about him? |
What you said about Confucianism are what I dislike about it as well
however, keep in mind there are other philosophies than Confucianism like the Lao Tzu you mentioned and Daoism etc.
Some of those are very similiar to western mentality and even more "western" than the west in a sense. I think its time for the chinese to change thier philosophy from Confucianism to other more suitable chinese philosophies for the modern time.
As for the influence remained, communism in mainland china had decreased much influence of Confucianism
276
Aug 14 2004, 12:54 AM
| QUOTE (ZurichGrrl @ Aug 13 2004, 09:00 PM) |
| QUOTE (276 @ Aug 13 2004, 06:07 PM) | Confucianism is prevalent in Korea, but I have to say that it's also holding the country back. I think Korea is very backwards because of its predominant Confucianist mentality. Some examples are its repression of women, stress on order stymieing creativity, lack of individuality. It's only recently shedding its shackles in becoming more westernized.
I've recently been reading Lao Tzu, and find his philosophy and writings fascinating. Can anyone tell me more about him? |
What you said about Confucianism are what I dislike about it as well however, keep in mind there are other philosophies than Confucianism like the Lao Tzu you mentioned and Daoism etc. Some of those are very similiar to western mentality and even more "western" than the west in a sense. I think its time for the chinese to change thier philosophy from Confucianism to other more suitable chinese philosophies for the modern time. As for the influence remained, communism in mainland china had decreased much influence of Confucianism
|
How is Daoism similar to western philosophy?
I agree, there are some useful parts of Confucianism, but it's done a great deal of cultural damage to countries that practice it--Korea, Japan, and you mentioned China.
ZurichGrrl
Aug 14 2004, 01:11 AM
| QUOTE (276 @ Aug 14 2004, 01:54 AM) |
How is Daoism similar to western philosophy?
|
I'm not saying Doaism, but since you mentioned it; for starters like gender equality(actually in Doaism they emphasis the female over male) and sexual freedom etc
fiji
Aug 14 2004, 01:20 AM
Yes, Confucianism is very backward and it kept all people down, since they should worship their ruler. Women mistreated. Man, I'm pissed everytime I catch a glimpse of one of those Korean series.
I don't understand how if the Mongols were to rule longer Asian would be able to stand up to white people. I think it would be opposite, Asian would be treated way worse. The Mongol themselves put Chinese at the bottom, they treated muslim and whites better than they do Asian. If they did rule all of Asia and longer, they would make us like Africans.
276
Aug 14 2004, 01:24 AM
| QUOTE (fiji @ Aug 14 2004, 02:20 AM) |
Yes, Confucianism is very backward and it kept all people down, since they should worship their ruler. Women mistreated. Man, I'm pissed everytime I catch a glimpse of one of those Korean series.
I don't understand how if the Mongols were to rule longer Asian would be able to stand up to white people. I think it would be opposite, Asian would be treated way worse. The Mongol themselves put Chinese at the bottom, they treated muslim and whites better than they do Asian. If they did rule all of Asia and longer, they would make us like Africans. |
How are Manchus related to what we're saying about Confucianism?
The one good thing about the Manchus, they united all of China.
276
Aug 14 2004, 01:26 AM
| QUOTE (ZurichGrrl @ Aug 14 2004, 02:11 AM) |
| QUOTE (276 @ Aug 14 2004, 01:54 AM) | How is Daoism similar to western philosophy?
|
I'm not saying Doaism, but since you mentioned it; for starters like gender equality(actually in Doaism they emphasis the female over male) and sexual freedom etc
|
Sorry I meant to say philosophy of Lao Tzu---how is it related to western philosophy?
ZurichGrrl
Aug 14 2004, 01:26 AM
| QUOTE (276 @ Aug 14 2004, 02:24 AM) |
| QUOTE (fiji @ Aug 14 2004, 02:20 AM) | Yes, Confucianism is very backward and it kept all people down, since they should worship their ruler. Women mistreated. Man, I'm pissed everytime I catch a glimpse of one of those Korean series.
I don't understand how if the Mongols were to rule longer Asian would be able to stand up to white people. I think it would be opposite, Asian would be treated way worse. The Mongol themselves put Chinese at the bottom, they treated muslim and whites better than they do Asian. If they did rule all of Asia and longer, they would make us like Africans. |
How are Manchus related to what we're saying about Confucianism?
The one good thing about the Manchus, they united all of China.
|
what?he's talking about Mongols and you're talking about Manchus
and Manchus did not unite China
276
Aug 14 2004, 01:30 AM
| QUOTE (ZurichGrrl @ Aug 14 2004, 02:26 AM) |
| QUOTE (276 @ Aug 14 2004, 02:24 AM) | | QUOTE (fiji @ Aug 14 2004, 02:20 AM) | Yes, Confucianism is very backward and it kept all people down, since they should worship their ruler. Women mistreated. Man, I'm pissed everytime I catch a glimpse of one of those Korean series.
I don't understand how if the Mongols were to rule longer Asian would be able to stand up to white people. I think it would be opposite, Asian would be treated way worse. The Mongol themselves put Chinese at the bottom, they treated muslim and whites better than they do Asian. If they did rule all of Asia and longer, they would make us like Africans. |
How are Manchus related to what we're saying about Confucianism?
The one good thing about the Manchus, they united all of China.
|
what?he's talking about Mongols and you're talking about Manchus and Manchus did not unite China
|
my mistake. It's getting late and I'm tired.
Manchus did acquire more provinces, making China larger--except they oppressed the Chinese people.
ZurichGrrl
Aug 14 2004, 01:32 AM
| QUOTE (276 @ Aug 14 2004, 02:26 AM) |
| QUOTE (ZurichGrrl @ Aug 14 2004, 02:11 AM) | | QUOTE (276 @ Aug 14 2004, 01:54 AM) | How is Daoism similar to western philosophy?
|
I'm not saying Doaism, but since you mentioned it; for starters like gender equality(actually in Doaism they emphasis the female over male) and sexual freedom etc
|
Sorry I meant to say philosophy of Lao Tzu---how is it related to western philosophy?
|
Lao Tsu eh...I'm afraid I don't have enough knowledge about Lao Tsu to answer your question
its very complicated as well...plus which exact western philosophy are you refering to?
maybe some other people here can do a better job than me
276
Aug 14 2004, 01:45 AM
| QUOTE (ZurichGrrl @ Aug 14 2004, 02:32 AM) |
| QUOTE (276 @ Aug 14 2004, 02:26 AM) | | QUOTE (ZurichGrrl @ Aug 14 2004, 02:11 AM) | | QUOTE (276 @ Aug 14 2004, 01:54 AM) | How is Daoism similar to western philosophy?
|
I'm not saying Doaism, but since you mentioned it; for starters like gender equality(actually in Doaism they emphasis the female over male) and sexual freedom etc
|
Sorry I meant to say philosophy of Lao Tzu---how is it related to western philosophy?
|
Lao Tsu eh...I'm afraid I don't have enough knowledge about Lao Tsu to answer your question its very complicated as well...plus which exact western philosophy are you refering to? maybe some other people here can do a better job than me
|
I've been reading about the concept of self-government, which was a quite sophisticated and pro-western. The amazing thing is Tzu was writing this like 1000 years before the westerners.
ZurichGrrl
Aug 14 2004, 01:48 AM
| QUOTE (276 @ Aug 14 2004, 02:45 AM) |
| I've been reading about the concept of self-government, which was a quite sophisticated and pro-western. The amazing thing is Tzu was writing this like 1000 years before the westerners. |
there you go...so I guess that resembles the idea of Therou
I bet there are more...need to find time and study
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please
click here.