Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Taiwan business leader calls for peace law with China
Asia Finest Discussion Forum > Asian Culture > Chinese Chat > Taiwanese Chat
BigBenChow
QUOTE
Taiwan business leader calls for peace law with China

Nov 12, 2007, 5:32 GMT

Taipei - A Taiwan business leader on Monday urged the ruling party and opposition presidential candidates to sign a peace law to end five decades of hostility between Taiwan and China.

In a half-page ad in three newspapers, Robert Tsao, chairman of the United Microelectronics Corp (UMC), the world's second-largest chipmaker, urged DPP presidential candidate Frank Hsieh and KMT presidential candidate Ma Ying-jeou to sign the Peaceful Co-existence Bill after they have won the presidential election on March 22, 2008.

Tsao said that for Taiwan's peace and prosperity, the future leader of Taiwan should sign the Peaceful Co-Existence Bill to formally end hostility with China.

China, in turn, should grant Taiwan a high degree of autonomy, he said.

Tsao said Taiwan should scrap the referendum on joining the United Nations - planned for March 22, 2008 - which has irked China, and can hold a unification referendum instead, if Beijing makes the request.

Tsao's ad is the latest call for improving ties with China from Taiwan business leaders who blame strained cross-Strait ties for the deterioration of Taiwan's economy.

In response to Tsao's proposal, opposition presidential candidate Ma said he will launch peace talks with China to seek to sign a peace pact.

'But the pre-condition for the talks is that China must first remove the missiles targeting Taiwan,' Ma said.

China has deployed nearly 800 missiles on its south-east coast facing Taiwan.


Then the peace talks will fail. There should never be any pre conditions to negotiations.
Red Fox Ace
QUOTE(BigBenChow @ Mar 6 2008, 09:40 AM) [snapback]3548856[/snapback]
Then the peace talks will fail. There should never be any pre conditions to negotiations.


Why not? All the time, China insists that negotiations must be based off of Taiwan accepting "One China" before the talks can start.
BigBenChow
QUOTE(Red Fox Ace @ Mar 7 2008, 12:21 AM) [snapback]3548904[/snapback]
Why not? All the time, China insists that negotiations must be based off of Taiwan accepting "One China" before the talks can start.


And has these negotiations worked?

Or even happened?

Or has Chen Shui Bian even accepted the pre condition?
progen

Well, China does not insist Taiwan be a part of ROC/China or PRC/China.

It is just Taiwan is a part of "China."

Why not accept the precondition. It is in Taiwan's constitution anyway.

Suijen
That's fine, move the missiles away. It doesn't mean that the PRC promises it won't invade.
Iki
QUOTE(Suijen @ Mar 6 2008, 10:17 PM) [snapback]3549819[/snapback]
That's fine, move the missiles away. It doesn't mean that the PRC promises it won't invade.


One step on taiwan and you will have the US right up on china's @ss... I would like to see them try.... kiss.gif
lilzz
actually the ideal situation for now is integration and not unification. Because if Taiwan got unified, then US would treat them differently and not allow the very high tech stuffs to Taiwan. If more integration, the trickle down effect of Taiwan getting US commercial high tech which in terms bring it to CHina, bring it the motherland. Taiwan would play the middle man role.

I am all for sign a peace treaty and then much higher integration between China and Taiwan.
Red Fox Ace
QUOTE(BigBenChow @ Mar 6 2008, 09:40 AM) [snapback]3548856[/snapback]
Then the peace talks will fail. There should never be any pre conditions to negotiations.


Or let's put it this way, is it reasonable to expect someone to negotiate when you're putting him at gunpoint?
BigBenChow
QUOTE(Red Fox Ace @ Mar 11 2008, 04:02 AM) [snapback]3556946[/snapback]
Or let's put it this way, is it reasonable to expect someone to negotiate when you're putting him at gunpoint?


China and US does it all the time. icon_rolleyes.gif.

And stop being a drama queen. A few missiles won't sink Taiwan. icon_wink.gif
Red Fox Ace
QUOTE(BigBenChow @ Mar 10 2008, 02:50 PM) [snapback]3557022[/snapback]
China and US does it all the time. icon_rolleyes.gif.


When?

QUOTE(BigBenChow @ Mar 10 2008, 02:50 PM) [snapback]3557022[/snapback]
And stop being a drama queen. A few missiles won't sink Taiwan. icon_wink.gif


China's 900+ Dong Feng missiles are widely seen as the opening blow in a Taiwan invasion scenario. Take away these missiles, and the threat of PLA attack is greatly diminished in effectiveness.

BigBenChow
QUOTE(Red Fox Ace @ Mar 11 2008, 06:00 AM) [snapback]3557084[/snapback]
When?


What do you mean when? the US constantly has forward forces on standby against China. Does this stop China and US from having a mutual beneficial relationship? no.

QUOTE(Red Fox Ace @ Mar 11 2008, 06:00 AM) [snapback]3557084[/snapback]
China's 900+ Dong Feng missiles are widely seen as the opening blow in a Taiwan invasion scenario. Take away these missiles, and the threat of PLA attack is greatly diminished in effectiveness.


Then don't give the PRC an excuse to invade...
Red Fox Ace
QUOTE(BigBenChow @ Mar 10 2008, 04:58 PM) [snapback]3557182[/snapback]
What do you mean when? the US constantly has forward forces on standby against China. Does this stop China and US from having a mutual beneficial relationship? no.


China and the USA aren’t conducting peace talks or possible frameworks for reunification.

QUOTE(BigBenChow @ Mar 10 2008, 04:58 PM) [snapback]3557182[/snapback]
Then don't give the PRC an excuse to invade...


The PRC needs no excuse to invade. The threat of invasion has always been there no matter what Taiwan’s stance.



progen
QUOTE(Red Fox Ace @ Mar 10 2008, 03:02 PM) [snapback]3556946[/snapback]
Or let's put it this way, is it reasonable to expect someone to negotiate when you're putting him at gunpoint?


Your view of China is consistent with people who know nothing about China (or never have been to China).

Those Taiwanese who have been to China?

Well, there are a few millions of them, and they are happily doing business and making money in China.

Gunpoint? They will laugh at your face, actually.

So there you are. Those who know and those who don't really know.
Red Fox Ace
QUOTE(progen @ Mar 10 2008, 05:54 PM) [snapback]3557320[/snapback]
Your view of China is consistent with people who know nothing about China (or have been to China).


Never been to China? I don’t know if you were reading in the other thread, but I mentioned – twice – that I have been to China many times before, to Fujian, Beijing, inner Mongolia and other places.

QUOTE(progen @ Mar 10 2008, 05:54 PM) [snapback]3557320[/snapback]
Those Taiwanese who have been to China?

Well, there are a few millions of them, and they are happily doing business and making money in China.


We were discussing peace talks. What does that have to do with Taiwanese businessmen in China? They’re not going to be the ones sitting down at a conference table and talking with Hu Jintao, will they?
BigBenChow
QUOTE(Red Fox Ace @ Mar 11 2008, 07:35 AM) [snapback]3557275[/snapback]
China and the USA aren’t conducting peace talks or possible frameworks for reunification.

Whats the difference between peace talks and talks on North Korea. or Talks on military transparency. or talks on human rights?. or talks on trade disputes?

QUOTE(Red Fox Ace @ Mar 11 2008, 07:35 AM) [snapback]3557275[/snapback]
The PRC needs no excuse to invade. The threat of invasion has always been there no matter what Taiwan’s stance.



Anti Secession law.... a law formalizing the long-standing policy of the People's Republic of China to use "non-peaceful means" against the "Taiwan independence movement".
progen
QUOTE
Never been to China? I don’t know if you were reading in the other thread, but I mentioned â€â€œ twice â€â€œ that I have been to China many times before, to Fujian, Beijing, inner Mongolia and other places.


What, you have been to China as a spy?

Really, based on your postings (and I have been reading quit a few now), I can bet that you have never been to China.

Why don't you confess, or provide some proof?
Red Fox Ace
QUOTE(progen @ Mar 10 2008, 06:00 PM) [snapback]3557335[/snapback]
Really, based on your postings (and I have been reading quit a few now), I can bet that you have never been to China.


What is "someone who has been to China" supposed to look like, in your opinion? Someone who can't stop praising the merits of Taiwan-China reunification, or someone who strongly supports the CCP, or what? You seem to be someone given to quick stereotyping.
progen
QUOTE(Red Fox Ace @ Mar 10 2008, 07:12 PM) [snapback]3557355[/snapback]
What is "someone who has been to China" supposed to look like, in your opinion? Someone who can't stop praising the merits of Taiwan-China reunification, or someone who strongly supports the CCP, or what? You seem to be someone given to quick stereotyping.


Your profile does not fit for someone who has any personal knowledge of China.

So just confess and admit that you have never been to China. Be brave. laugh.gif
Red Fox Ace
QUOTE(progen @ Mar 10 2008, 06:20 PM) [snapback]3557369[/snapback]
Your profile does not fit for someone who has any personal knowledge of China.



Your stereotyping amazes me more and more. You think that everyone who's been to China fits the same profile? Do you think everyone who's been to the USA fits the same profile?

Actually, my profile does fit - someone who has personal knowledge of China can have a wide variety of opinions. The problem is you, who think that "everyone who's been to China must fit into the same mold and think exactly the same way and say exactly the same things."
progen
QUOTE(Red Fox Ace @ Mar 10 2008, 07:32 PM) [snapback]3557404[/snapback]
Your stereotyping amazes me more and more. You think that everyone who's been to China fits the same profile? Do you think everyone who's been to the USA fits the same profile?

Actually, my profile does fit - someone who has personal knowledge of China can have a wide variety of opinions. The problem is you, who think that "everyone who's been to China must fit into the same mold and think exactly the same way and say exactly the same things."


I am not stereotyping you. Your profile is consisted what you said or do over a period of time. It actually tells people a lot about you.

Your knowledge of China is limited because you have no experience or personal knowledge of China. You might know a lot of facts about China, but your knowledge of China, a placed that you have never visited, it still limited to what you read or heard.

For example, I have never been to Iran. My view of Iran is based on what I read or heard, but that is really a far cry from the reality.

So you still refuse to confess.
Red Fox Ace



QUOTE(progen @ Mar 10 2008, 06:48 PM) [snapback]3557456[/snapback]
Your profile is consisted what you said or do over a period of time. It actually tells people a lot about you.


So then, tell me, what does it say? Does it say I’m a rabid Taiwan independence supporter? (I’m not.) Does it say I’m some Amnesty Intentional human rights activist? (I’m not.) Does it say I’m a Falun Gonger? (I’m not.)

QUOTE(progen @ Mar 10 2008, 06:48 PM) [snapback]3557456[/snapback]
Your knowledge of China is limited because you have no experience or personal knowledge of China. You might know a lot of facts about China, but your knowledge of China, a placed that you have never visited, it still limited to what you read or heard.


How about this:

I’ve been to a rural inn in Inner Mongolia. I can tell you, from experience, that one of the inns there is a surprise for a rural place: Its food is amazingly good. They serve fried diced chicken (in a light, hot crust), spinach, white rice, and other things. The intriguing thing when my family visited this inn was that the food was better than it was in many urban places in China, like Beijing or Fujian. Usually rural food is supposed to be lousy in comparison to urban places – but this place wasn’t.

And the public bathrooms in China, in many places, are basically stalls with holes in the ground that open to a pit below – in other words, no water or flushing involved. Just a pit with a hole covering in a wooden floor platform.


That good enough for you? (Wait, you’re going to tell me next that all of this can’t be verified.)


QUOTE(progen @ Mar 10 2008, 06:48 PM) [snapback]3557456[/snapback]
Your knowledge of China is limited because you have no experience or personal knowledge of China. You might know a lot of facts about China, but your knowledge of China, a placed that you have never visited, it still limited to what you read or heard.


Why don’t you tell me a thing or two about what being in China is like?
progen
Man, you are cracking me up. When did you visit China? In the 70s? No, you are not that old.

So someone told you about the $hitholes. But let me tell you a little secret. $hitholes are no longer used in China, unless you go to a remote village in the mountains. Chinese cities today make Taipei look like a second or third rated city.

Talk to one of your Taiwanese friends who have been in China or live in China. They will tell you what China is really like.

Your view of China is not different from my view of Iran. They are not coming from personal experience, and you know it.
Red Fox Ace
QUOTE(progen @ Mar 10 2008, 07:13 PM) [snapback]3557529[/snapback]
So someone told you about the $hitholes. But let me tell you a little secret. $hitholes are no longer used in China, unless you go to a remote village in the mountains



So I've been to remote villages. And there were $hitholes. So? Nothing's being contradicted.


Who’s been to China and who hasn’t? Are you telling me that I’m wrong factually, when I’ve been there by experience and know for myself? Look, I might have to be the one asking you if you’ve ever been to China, not you asking me.


Have you ever been to China? Give me a break.
crabdonut
QUOTE(progen @ Mar 10 2008, 07:13 PM) [snapback]3557529[/snapback]
Man, you are cracking me up. When did you visit China? In the 70s? No, you are not that old.

So someone told you about the $hitholes. But let me tell you a little secret. $hitholes are no longer used in China, unless you go to a remote village in the mountains. Chinese cities today make Taipei look like a second or third rated city.

Talk to one of your Taiwanese friends who have been in China or live in China. They will tell you what China is really like.

Your view of China is not different from my view of Iran. They are not coming from personal experience, and you know it.


Actually I went to China last year and some places in urban cities still had $hitholes.
Suijen
The basis for negotiations is "There is only one China, and the ROC is part of that China and that the ROC is inseparable from that China".

The reason this is a precondition for negotiations is because, quite simply, that's the absolute minimum China's willing to accept regardless. If the ROC cannot accede to that, then negotiations won't really go anywhere regardless.
progen
QUOTE(Red Fox Ace @ Mar 10 2008, 08:51 PM) [snapback]3557609[/snapback]
So I've been to remote villages. And there were $hitholes. So? Nothing's being contradicted.
Who’s been to China and who hasn’t? Are you telling me that I’m wrong factually, when I’ve been there by experience and know for myself? Look, I might have to be the one asking you if you’ve ever been to China, not you asking me.
Have you ever been to China? Give me a break.


That is funny. China is such a fasincating place. Take Beijing for example. You have the Great Wall, the Forbidden City, The Tiananmen Square, the Ming Tomb, Beijing Musems, the Beihai Park, the University district,.... I can go on and on. It was the capital of so many great Chinese dynasties.

Also, how about the great 21st century architectural designs?

However, you can only remember $hitholes in a remote village in the mountains?

I hate to say it, but you are full of it. Confession time, ha ha ha....
Red Fox Ace
QUOTE(progen @ Mar 10 2008, 08:35 PM) [snapback]3557740[/snapback]
That is funny. China is such a fasincating place. Take Beijing for example. You have the Great Wall, the Forbidden City, The Tiananmen Square, the Ming Tomb, Beijing Musems, the Beihai Park, the University district,.... I can go on and on. It was the capital of so many great Chinese dynasties.

Give me a break. All of these are famous landmarks and anyone could write up a fake essay about what he knows about them, from research on the Web. Don't you think that if I had made a post about it, you would accuse me of faking it?
Red Fox Ace
I have yet to hear you describe what your "profile of someone who has not been to China" looks like.
Suijen
This isn't about toilets you two.
Iki
QUOTE(Red Fox Ace @ Mar 10 2008, 09:44 PM) [snapback]3557772[/snapback]
I have yet to hear you describe what your "profile of someone who has not been to China" looks like.


He is basing it off of your views... which I think is ignorant...
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2013 Invision Power Services, Inc.