Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: German court upholds incest law
Asia Finest Discussion Forum > Asian Culture > Other Culture
glinnjinn
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/7294022.stm

German court upholds incest law



Germany's highest court has upheld the law making incest a criminal offence, rejecting an appeal from a man who has had four children with his sister.
The court ruled that the state was within its rights to protect "family order" and prevent the serious genetic illnesses that could arise from incest.

The man, identified as Patrick S, has already spent time in prison for incest but has been free pending his appeal.

He was adopted and only met his sister in 2000 when he met his birth mother.

The Federal Constitutional Court said the law against incest was in line with Germany's constitution.

One judge dissented, however, saying the punishment must match the offence and that the law "is based exclusively on moral beliefs rather than with the objective of legal protection".

'Consequences'

Patrick S has served more than two years of the two-and-a-half year sentence he was given in 2005. He now faces the possibility of returning to prison to serve out the remainder.


All but one of the couple's children have been taken into care

His sister, Susan, was also convicted of incest and placed on probation for one year.

Patrick's lawyer, Endrik Wilhelm, argued that the law against incest was a "historical relic" and the couple were doing no harm to others.

But the court said that sexual relations between siblings "do not affect them exclusively, but also can have an effect on family and society and have consequences for children who arise from the relationship".

Patrick S, from Leipzig, was adopted when he was four years old and met his sister in 2000 when he tracked down his birth mother.

He was 24 at the time and she 16.

Their four children are aged from six years to 34 months. Three of them are in foster care.


boinky78
I really cant even hate on 16 year olds dating etc 20 somethins
that would just make me a hypocrite embarassedlaugh.gif
not gonna comment on that bit
but any who
I kind of dont see a problem with incest depends on the situation
they seem inlove and doing great
glinnjinn
QUOTE(boinky78 @ Mar 19 2008, 03:52 AM) [snapback]3578208[/snapback]
I really cant even hate on 16 year olds dating etc 20 somethins
that would just make me a hypocrite embarassedlaugh.gif
not gonna comment on that bit
but any who
I kind of dont see a problem with incest depends on the situation
they seem inlove and doing great

I can't believe a person would say such a thing, beyond sick. icon_neutral.gif

you don't see a problem with marrying a sibling, a brother or sister? jawdrop.gif What the fu-k is wrong with the world. Or is it a asian thing? What religion do you follow, that allows incest? icon_neutral.gif
Takashi
Already posted.
boinky78
QUOTE(glinnjinn @ Mar 19 2008, 05:00 AM) [snapback]3578220[/snapback]
I can't believe a person would say such a thing, beyond sick. icon_neutral.gif

you don't see a problem with marrying a sibling, a brother or sister? jawdrop.gif What the fu-k is wrong with the world. Or is it a asian thing? What religion do you follow, that allows incest? icon_neutral.gif

I don't follow any kind of religion
don't see the problem because they werent raised as brother and sister
so they see each other in a different way
if you think about it
werent adam and eve practicing incest? embarassedlaugh.gif
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2010 Invision Power Services, Inc.