Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Lawmaker wants to abolish boxing in the Philippines
Asia Finest Discussion Forum > Asian Culture > Filipino Chat
masipag2
http://www.gmanews.tv/story/86027/Lawmaker...the-Philippines
QUOTE
People may never see newly crowned WBC featherweight champion Manny Pacquiao fighting inside the ring here in the Philippines – that is, if a bill filed in the House of Representatives should become a law banning "violent sports," like boxing.

Nueva Ecija Rep. Eduardo Joson, author of House Bill No. 3743, said boxing is a dangerous sport whose basic intent is to inflict physical injury on the opponent.

He cited studies showing boxing incidents that resulted permanent damage to the fighter like brain injury and sight and hearing loss – and even death.

"Sometimes, a single punch does the damage," Joson said. "But in other cases, it is the overall effect of hundreds of punches over the many fights fought by the boxer throughout his career. For this reason, and in line with the policy of the state to promote sports for the development of a healthy and alert citizenry, the author hereby seeks to put a complete ban on boxing contest and or exhibition."

Joson also noted that fame and money a few successful boxers sends a tempting message to the youth, especially those who belong to poor families.

"Many young boys are lured to go into boxing because of that," he said.

The bill seeks to penalize a boxer with prision correccional (six months and one day to six years) and fine of not less than P200 but not more than P6,000.

Joson said no amount of money can compensate for permanent brain damage and premature death of a boxer.

Last year, boxer Angelito Sisnorio, a native of Koronadal City, died after getting head injuries in a bout in Thailand . - Fidel Jimenez, GMANews.TV


What do you guys think about this?
martin_nuke
Boxing is really a dangerous and lethal sport look what happened to 3 time world champion Muhamed Ali, he has brain damage. I think all professional boxers are aware of this that is why many retire early because they do not want to have brain damage or die. Training should be supervised by a profesional trainer so if its illegal training, it should be against to law because boxing is a dangerous sport.
god056
sigh

Boxing has long been established as dangerous. That's the main reason why boxers are made to wear gloves during their fights.

I think the issue in that article (for me atleast) is whether that politician is really concerned about boxer's welfares. That or he is just riding with the tide of boxing fame.
P. Bredahl
bull$hit.. all they want is peoples money.

might aswell ban any form of competitive free diving and bike sport especially and basketball, football(soccer) as they cause many many many more injuries worldwide than any competitive martial art.
sitataymo
So what's a poor guy to do when there isn't any opportunities left?

I'm sensing this guy didn't get his cut or lost a bet when Pacman won the fight laugh.gif
flipcombatmedic
being a journalist is dangerous in the philippines what they going to ban it too? i think they should focus on implementing some of the laws that are not being executed or executed properly than stupid laws they try to make.
Digital Insanity
Putang ina niya! Anong nasaisip ng gunggong na 'to? HOY, DAMUHO, KUNG MAY MAGANDA KANG NASASAISIP, GAWIN MO 'YON, ALANG-ALANG SA 'PINAS!

HANGAL! >_>
Iki
Boxing can really fuk you up though. But this guy is obviously asking for an attention....
flippityflop
.
NeoVxR
These guys should focus more on the economic ethics of sports, but of course they are coming with the same boat and make a living on the meta informal level like all media and politicians do.

I wonder why smoking is more and more forbidden in the Western countries, while boxing, car racing, and many other dangerous sports are hailed and hyped.
Probably I have to answer myself "It's the economy, stupid!"

I am all for sports on the grassroots level, like Chinese QiGong/WuXiu (sorry if bad spelling) and village soccer etc..

But sport do NOT generate wealth, just Big Money is MOVED upwards, from those who work in production to those who organize and "own" sports enterprises, and some of the celebrities get insanely wealthy, becoming heroes and role models just for running faster or beating the $hit of another human.

I just ask people to see the disbalance. Rich countries can afford the kind of hyped sports that is shown in international TV (which is also due to vast export! - can you spell "licensing"...), but with the poorer countries, they may experience another engine of exploitation, because the huge part of revenue ends up in the pockets of the already wealthy few, possibly foreign enterprises.
It is not bad to make money move in the Capitalist world, but the physical creation of wealth is the ground of all the flow, and the only physical achievement of sports is health, and the other big factor is export and fame which have to be kept in reasonable sizes and places, or the tail would wag the dog..

Boxing or singing may help some individuals, but not the country. Eventually, those who bake bread or work in the industries have to pay for that all. It is all good culture, but only as far as it can be afforded and is feasible, and when there is not too much wealth pulled away from the common people.
Patton
QUOTE(god056 @ Mar 30 2008, 11:49 PM) [snapback]3606545[/snapback]
sigh

Boxing has long been established as dangerous. That's the main reason why boxers are made to wear gloves during their fights.

Ironically if you are to believe the UFC type fighters the gloves only served to make the dangerous "looking" cuts less likely. And in the end the gloves serve to protect the fighters hands, allowing them to punch harder and cause more brain injuries like Ali likely suffered over his career.
flipcombatmedic
QUOTE(flippityflop @ Apr 1 2008, 02:22 AM) [snapback]3608602[/snapback]
maybe Eduardo Joson was just discouraging boxing, because too many poor pinoys might get to it, seeing boxing as an easy way out of poverty. icon_neutral.gif

you know, like how some pinoys see showbiz as a chance to strike it rich...

first off, boxing had been huge in the philippines for a long time. so the 'might get to it' is quiet puzzling because it would have been so by now.

second, there's nothing wrong with 'ways out of poverty' AS LONG as it is not illegal. but for some reason criminal activities prevention (legislation as such not only to further prevent and control crime) is not given focus by such a caring legislator.
Athrun340
QUOTE(martin_nuke @ Mar 31 2008, 01:30 AM) [snapback]3606466[/snapback]
Boxing is really a dangerous and lethal sport look what happened to 3 time world champion Muhamed Ali, he has brain damage. I think all professional boxers are aware of this that is why many retire early because they do not want to have brain damage or die. Training should be supervised by a profesional trainer so if its illegal training, it should be against to law because boxing is a dangerous sport.

Muhammed Ali has parkinson's disease not brain damage.
Sonofvisayas
Riiiiight papansin ang putz
ronin
Hopefully, his numbnut will probably not last long in office if he presents this bill. And what business is it to him if a young person wants to choose boxing. It's their choice. The only danger is to the boxer's and his opponents' health which is their personal medical business. There's no danger to the general public. He should concentrate on other important things if he's really concerned about the people like investing in a science and technology campus in the Philippines to create indigenous technology products that can be exported or help set up vocational schools for at risk kids so that they can be skilled workers who can contribute to the economy.
*promo
QUOTE(Athrun340 @ Apr 1 2008, 01:08 PM) [snapback]3609380[/snapback]
Muhammed Ali has parkinson's disease not brain damage.



LOOL embarassedlaugh.gif embarassedlaugh.gif embarassedlaugh.gif pwnd him.
flippityflop
.
martin_nuke
QUOTE(Athrun340 @ Apr 1 2008, 03:08 PM) [snapback]3609380[/snapback]
Muhammed Ali has parkinson's disease not brain damage.

PD is the most common cause of chronic progressive parkinsonism, a term which refers to the syndrome of tremor, rigidity, bradykinesia and postural instability. PD is also called "primary parkinsonism" or "idiopathic PD" (classically meaning having no known cause although this term is not strictly true in light of the plethora of newly discovered genetic mutations). While many forms of parkinsonism are "idiopathic", "secondary" cases may result from toxicity most notably drugs, head trauma, or other medical disorders.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parkinson's_disease

AMA Queensland President Dr Steve Hambleton also has called for boxing to be removed from the Games bill, saying brain damage and debilitating diseases such as Parkinson's are recognised consequences of boxing.
http://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/41288.php

Recent studies of brain damage in boxers have shown that they can suffer injuries to many parts of the brain, in addition to the area associated with Parkinson's disease. Such damage produces a variety of symptoms, most commonly poor coordination, a broad-based gait, slurred speech and mental deterioration.
http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html...75AC0A962948260

I love boxing as a sport but I think that Professional Boxers should have a limit of fights in their career to avoid Parkinson's are recognised consequences of boxing.
Athrun340
QUOTE(martin_nuke @ Apr 2 2008, 12:28 AM) [snapback]3610366[/snapback]
PD is the most common cause of chronic progressive parkinsonism, a term which refers to the syndrome of tremor, rigidity, bradykinesia and postural instability. PD is also called "primary parkinsonism" or "idiopathic PD" (classically meaning having no known cause although this term is not strictly true in light of the plethora of newly discovered genetic mutations). While many forms of parkinsonism are "idiopathic", "secondary" cases may result from toxicity most notably drugs, head trauma, or other medical disorders.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parkinson's_disease

AMA Queensland President Dr Steve Hambleton also has called for boxing to be removed from the Games bill, saying brain damage and debilitating diseases such as Parkinson's are recognised consequences of boxing.
http://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/41288.php

Recent studies of brain damage in boxers have shown that they can suffer injuries to many parts of the brain, in addition to the area associated with Parkinson's disease. Such damage produces a variety of symptoms, most commonly poor coordination, a broad-based gait, slurred speech and mental deterioration.
http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html...75AC0A962948260

I love boxing as a sport but I think that Professional Boxers should have a limit of fights in their career to avoid Parkinson's are recognised consequences of boxing.

sir, you're confused. Brain damage and Parkinson's are not the same.

btw, your first link says it all "classically meaning having no known cause" Your 2nd link, on the other hand, is just somones opinion and doesn't prove anything. The third one, if you notice, was published September of 1984. We're already in 2008

I would not deny the fact tho that boxing can cause brain damage, but IMO banning boxing is not the solution. GAB needs to do a better job supervising our boxers just like what happened to sisnorio's case thumbsdown.gif
santoloco
hell no please. i love boxing too much! cry2.gif
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2009 Invision Power Services, Inc.