QUOTE(khamara @ Apr 28 2008, 02:06 PM) [snapback]3666761[/snapback]
I hope I don't offend you or your company.So how do you present your work? Don't give me wrong....someone with camera and alittle bit of creativity can accomplish the same deal.. what I'm saying is show me what haven't done before, camera angle, usuage of media(camera) and so on....I think one that come to mind was the "blair Witch project" You knew what kind of camera they used,B/W footages.. so on so..
I don't find your respond offensive,but I found you're limited yourself to a certain aspect. I am an artist myself and I went thru a certain of training and experienced some of other mediums(art,videography,and mix media) that available out there...that's just my opinion,if you can't take criticism from your viewers,what's the purpose of making movie? just my .02
p.s. My criticism is base on what I seen on the video,Now If I seen the whole movie otherwise my comment probably state differently.
Khamara,
I don t know how you get from “originality” to “criticism”. I think you misunderstood what you were reading. I do not view your remark as a criticism. I was merely explaining about originality.
You’ve said you wanted people to show you something original. If you are in the film and/or an artist within the media industry you would not use such word. Like I have said before there is no such thing as originality. It is the background of the story itself will make the movie different.
To answer your statement about “someone with camera and a little bit of creativity can accomplish the same deal”, I have to disagree with that. Indeed one can pick up a camcorder and a flashlight and be able to achieve the same SHOTS but not the same DEAL. If simple as that, Hollywood would probably be out of business a long time ago. The Living Dangerously trailers have been shown to film industry all over the country. Not once has any filmmakers mentioned about camera angles, format, etc. Somehow when you shown it to Cambodians viewers all of them think they know everything there is to know about filmmaking. Why is that? I think they use the word “criticism” as an excuse to cover their real motive.
To shoot and edit in your house is and easy thing to do. Nowadays anyone can purchase editing software for less than a thousand dollars. More over, you can also get sound effects through the internet. The question is, why do filmmakers still spend million of dollars on their movie for sound effect and other stuff? Because they are not planning to put their work on YouTube.
I think you have been watching too much “Matrix” movies. There are limited to what you can do to achieve camera angles. Would it look right to do a matrix shot if you are making “Jurassic Park or Boyz N the Hood”? A certain shot it only work with a certain movie. And it is the filmmaker choice whether he/she chose to shoot on B/W film. If you want to talk about “Blair Watch Project” I can give you details down to the type of screws they used to mount the camera. But that is another store.
What bothered me most is when you said “
My criticism is base on what I seen on the video, Now If I seen the whole movie otherwise my comment probably state differently”
That is like saying you saw a girl walking down the street dressed in a hooker outfits and right away you call her a Hooker. Then you turned around and said well if I known her I would reconsider judgment. That’s don’t make sense to me.
I’ll tell you what. To prove my point I will make you a deal. Shoot something with your camera with the same quality as the trailer. Make sure you use the camera angles that have not been done before. Once you are done, upload it to YouTube and show me. If you be able to show me something new and original, I will write you a 20 thousand dollars check.
I hate to write this much but you need to understand what you are saying before saying it. I had the feeling you put a comment just for the sake of having a comment. Which there’s nothing wrong with that, but I think you need to understand certain things before making a comment.
Just because I write all of these don’t mean I have something against you. I just want you to understand that things are not as simple as one may think.