QUOTE (直隸總督 @ Sep 3 2004, 05:37 PM)
There's not enough Mongolian members here to participate. Since Mongolia is historically a part of China, and it's closely related to China than to any other Asian nation, so it's reasonable.
Historically Mongolia was, at certain periods in history, part of the empires of China in the same way parts of China or at one point, the whole (Yuan Dynasty) of China was, at certain periods in history, part of the empires of Mongolia. To claim that Mongolia is straight-up historically part of China is to distort the reality and succumb to overly nationalistic claims. However, I would say that the Mongols and their nomadic kinsmen that had united Mongolia, which includes the Xiongnu, Xianbei, Kok Turuks, Uygurs, Kirghiz, etc. are part of Chinese history. I would also say that Mongolia (at the least the people's physical appearance, their lifestyle, and their recent history as being satellites of the Soviet Union) are more closely related to Central Asian republics like Kazakhstan and Kyrgyzstan than to China, the only difference being that the Kazakhs and Kirghiz are Muslims while a large number of Mongols are Buddhist. But it just so happens that the old Manchu Qing empire was able to lord over Mongolia for most of the dynasty's existence that Outer Mongolia is still claimed by some extreme Chinese nationalists to be "rightfully" theirs.
QUOTE (浪淘音 @ Sep 5 2004, 10:21 PM)
Mongolians outlawed marriage between Han Chinese and Mongolians, you do realize this, yes?
Has it occurred to you that the Mongols, in the course of their conquests, pillaged and raped, like many other victorious armies? Steppe nomads like the Mongols weren't notorious for no reason. I recall in one battle (I forget the name) in northern China, about 50,000 girls jumped off the city walls when the Mongols were about to take the city.
QUOTE (浪淘音 @ Sep 5 2004, 10:21 PM)
they're is very little Mongolian blood in the Han population
That is in fact very wrong. When we are talking about the genetic makeup of the Han population, one can say it is mixed, and not very homogeneous. Especially talking about the northern Chinese, many of them contain some blood from Turko-Mongol steppe nomads. During the Age of Fragmentation, northern China was invaded by various non-Han peoples; I'm sure you've heard of the Five Hu. When the Northern Wei lorded over all the other kingdoms in northern China, many Xianbei (a proto-Mongol/Tungusic people) peoples were assimilated by the larger Han population, and the Northern Wei emperors encouraged sinicization. During the Tang Dynasty, there were large numbers of foreigners in Chang'an (this includes Persians, Arabs, Uygurs, Sogdians, etc. though they were mainly merchants) and intermarriage between Han and non-Han often happened. In the army, many Turkic mercenaries were hired by the Tang. In fact, several famous Tang generals were of foreign blood, and foreigners were even given administrative posts. During the Five Dynasties Ten Kingdoms period, most of the northern dynasties were established by Shatuo Turks. During the Song Dynasties, the Khitans (a proto-Mongol/Tungusic people) ruled northern China for a while, then came the Jurchens (Tungusic). After that came the Mongols, who ruled all of China. I'm sure not all of them would abide to the laws even if anti-inter-ethnic marriage laws were put. In fact, in Yunnan province, there were several families who were recognized to be possibly the descendants of Khitans or Mongols. During the Qing Dynasty, Mongol cavalries were conscripted by the Manchus and several units were placed all over China.
QUOTE (浪淘音 @ Sep 7 2004, 02:29 PM)
you can go anywhere you want, no need to be invited. even if you weren't invited, you should ride in on horse back and slaughter and eat the people who did not invite you
I am surprised that the Mongolians here are not angered at such ignorant and offending statements; Turko-Mongol steppe nomads were not known to be cannibals. Steppe societies were very militarized; generally, it could be said that such societies often produce many war-like individuals, though that is not always true. The Dzungar Mongols were so ferocious that I recall in the last battle against the Qing empire, the Manchus had to massacre all the captued Dzungars so they wouldn't be able to rise as a significant power again. It could be generally said that perhaps hundreds of years of Buddhist influence, propogated by the Manchus, effectively decreased the warrior spirit of the Mongolians.
QUOTE (freelance @ Nov 10 2004, 11:07 PM)
You Chinese are sick and greedy! You occupied Southern Mongolia, East TURKISTAN, AND TIBET. Now you are claiming Independent Mongolia as historical part of CHina. Stupid!
And which nation, when they have the strength to occupy other peoples' lands, isn't?