Ok, maybe I need to explain the difference between
formal tradition and
common practice.
Let me explain. There is a difference between what the "formal tradition" is and what has taken place as "common practice".
You may find it "common practice" that most of the married couples you know, came about through the "stealing" of a girl. Maybe this is how your parents got together. And, to be honest, that is how most Hmong men decided to do it. Most men in Laos/Thailand/Vietnam didn't have money (or pigs/cows/chickens). The poor outnumbered the rich. So, for the most part, it became accepted as the norm. But, is it the formal tradition? Nope. Absolutely not. There is one concept that you are missing out on here that our forefathers held onto dearly:
The Sacredness of a Girl's VirginityWhen you "steal" a girl, you've done one of the most horrendous things you could do to a girl's reputation in a Hmong community. Even if you've never even touched a hair on her head, you've socially de-flowered her. She is no longer pure in the eyes of the community. And I appreciate that in the traditional Hmong culture. They ACTUALLY respected a girl's virginity. Wow! You don't see that every day, now do you? Somehow we've lost these ideals of purity in our culture (and even as a society of human beings, but that's another topic for another day).
Go back and ask your parents. Ask a mekong. They know the traditions. They'll tell you the truth. Ask them what the "most honorable/respectful" way is. If they know the true cultural traditions, then they will tell you that "stealing" your wife is not it.
My personal experience:When I married my wife, I did it the "traditional" way. I took my dad/uncle/mekong to their house and asked respectfully. Of course, it was easy. My wife loved me and I loved her. They kind of knew it would happen. Her parents were very reasonable. They only asked for the typical $5,000. And on top of that, they threw a huge wedding party for us, a car for my wife, some $$$, and blankets (lol, OG's always give blankets) to go with it. So, in the end, I came out on top. I practically didn't have to pay a dime. It was pretty cheap if you ask me.
Anyways, it is debatable because common practices have changed so much, especially since the Hmong introduction to America. Heck, we don't even practice half (probably not even a quarter) of the traditions our parents practiced. Do you go to your girlfriends house and knock on their walls and speak to them in song with a flute? I doubt it. And if you did, your neighbors would probably call the cops on you.
Besides, you're Americans now. You can run off and get married in Las Vega by an Elvis look-alike preacher if you'd like. And honestly, there isn't a thing anyone can say or do about it
Doesn't matter which way you decide to get married, whether by asking, stealing, or a good ole' American wedding. Just remember that
marriage is sacred. It's supposed to be a lasting bond. Tradition or no tradition,
marry someone you love and can tolerate to live with the rest of your life. That's all that matters. I just don't want to see a thread on here about someone divorcing their spouse over stupid stuff.