QUOTE(baal @ Sep 5 2008, 06:06 PM)

EAD,
I'm not looking to get into it with you, but the portion of your post quoted above should be explained. Would you please do so?
LONG POST
Japan by constitution is not allowed to have an army. It has a defense force instead. South Korea does not need to abide by such restrictive laws which allows the countries military to grow however it sees fit. South Koreas armed forces number nearly 700,000. Its reserve forces number 4,500,000. Japans armed forces number barely over 200,000 and its reserve forces number under 60,000(I didnt type that wrong, its under sixty thousand). By shear numbers, South Korea is far superior. Training quality wise, South Korea is far ahead of Japan as well. The average South Korean male has 2 years of military service under one of the strictest and cruelest training regimes in the world. Military service is mandatory in South Korea while in Japan its not. The Japanese military on the other hand is for highschool dropouts who want to earn a salary after failing miserably in life(South Korea pays next to nothing for its draftees). Japan might spend more then South Korea on its army, but if you take into account the large amount of money the Japanese army pays its salary man recruits, Japans higher costs as well as the comforts, advertisements, recruiting stations and more it needs in order to satisfy and bring in new recruits(and to keep its recruits). Military expenditure between the two countries isnt really that different. Furthermore, unlike South Korea who prefers to spend money on trusted, tested, tried and true US military equipment, Japan prefers to buy US tech and then develop a Japanese equivalent that is usually much more expensive, inferior and pointless. They spendt billions on pointless research projects that usually end in failure. The JASDF spent god knows how much money on research for the F-2 program. The F-2 was originally designed to be a Japanese knock off of the F-16 with slight modification. The end result was a plane that was actually inferior to the original F-16 they intended to surpass. It was bulky, slow, its equipment was shoddy, turning was crap, bug after bug in its equipment and computers as well as delay after delay. The F-2 despite being similar and inferior to the F-16 costed 4 times as much as the F-16. A single F-16 would have mopped the floor with a F-2. 4 F-16s against one F-2 would have been over kill. South Korea on the other hand simply chose to upgrade and add more advanced features and modifications to their F-16s which resulted in far superior planes with less bugs to the F-2. The point im trying to make is that 1 dollar in South Koreas military goes a lot farther than in Japan. The modifications added to the F-15J is also another example of shoddy Japanese add ons and waste.
Tech wise South Korea is far far far far superior to Japan in ground engagements. Not only is the ROK army far superior in numbers but also in technology, tanks, artillery etc. A ground engagement with South Korea would be suicidal for the Japanese. Mind you that due to Japans defense status, it really has no way of invading South Korea or any other country.
Air wise South Korea deploys a wide array of fighters including the F-15K which is far superior to anything Japan has. South Korea has 39 F-15ks with another 21 arriving soon. Japans counter measure for the F-15K is the much inferior and much older F-15J which began its maiden flight in 1981 I believe. South Koreas F-15K on the other hand is relatively new with very recent technology(2005). The additional 21 F-15Ks arriving soon will be even more advanced with newer features(better engines for example). Combat wise the individual F-15K would easily destroy an enemy F-15J(not to mention that the ROK airforce is better and longer trained)Japan has around 140 F-15Js which is superior in numbers to South Koreas F-15Ks, HOWEVER the Japanese airforce would be stupid and suicidal to send all of them at once against South Koreas airforce. Combat wise the Japanese airforce has no counter measures against South Koreas F-15Ks. But thats not all. South Korea also has about 180 F-16s which are smaller, more agile, better at dog fights and close range combat compared to the F-15. Japan on the other hand has only 33 combat read F-2s to challenge South Koreas 180 F-16s. Remember what I said about the F-2 being inferior to the standard F-16? Well, the F-16 employed by the ROK airforce is a modified and superior version to the original. The F-15K and F-16 together syngergizes with each other to create a formidable fighting force. F-15ks would destroy Japans F-15Js at long range to long-mid range. And if Japans F-15Js get close enough, Korean F-16s will come screaming in towards them and destroy them at mid and close range with ease. Japan has no counter measure for South Koreas F-15ks much like how they have no counter measure for the numerically superior F-16s(Japans F-2s suck). That said, Japanese planes are also designed for self defense rather than offensive wars. They wouldnt do so well in an invasion attempt. Japanese planes cannot really invade South Korea. And even if they could, they would lose horribly to South Koreas SAMs, defensive positions and airforce. Being on the defense is also another huge advantage.
Navy wise, Japan beats South Korea in total power. HOWEVER, the Japanese navy really has no way of invading Korea , Dokdo or beating the ROK navy in combat. If a naval war were to occur, the ROK navy would wisely opt to go on the defensive. The Japanese navy despite being more numerous and superior in tonnage would still be distraught to fight South Korean ships in mine infested waters while being aided by the ROK airforce. Japanese ships despite their weight will still sink like stones if they hit a mine. And thats exactly what the ROK navy will do. Mine an area in order to prevent the Japanese navy from attacking. Then pick/harass their navy off with fast ships, subs and the airforce. If the JSDN decides to attack anyways, a large portion of their ships will be destroyed by mines while South Korean ships can fire and retreat at the same time. I'd also like to mention that South Koreas Sejong class Aegis destroyers are more advanced then any Japanese ships in their navy right now.
QUOTE(JessicaW @ Sep 5 2008, 06:10 PM)

North Korea can\'t even feed their own people without outside aid. How is this more powerful than Japan? How is this more powerful than even New Guinea? Power is more than how many men with guns you have.
It
cant feed its own people but it
can feed its army. Thats why Kim is in power. He diverts all food aid to the military. Appeasing the military is what keeps him in power and prevents coups.