QUOTE (Bounthy @ Mar 10 2006, 04:06 PM)

"""..project runway isnt about race, its about design. Therefore rooting based on her nationality is just idiot"""
Do you assume that the judges were a bunch of incompetent people who awarded a winner who did not merit to win, i.e because she was an Asian and/or a woman?
Rooting based on her nationality? You missed the point.
Did anyone here said they watched the show and specifically rooted for Chloe Dao at all cost for the sole reason she happens to be a south-east asian?
People here congratulated someone who was chosen as the winner of thre Project Runaway and who happens to be a former south-east asian refugee, like many of us. What's wrong with that?
"""people who dont know fashion clearly do not know what they want, therefore should not even be rooting for anyone. if they dont have a knowledge of fashion they shouldn't be allowed to critique designers.""""
HAHAHA!!! Please wake up, Chickery, and come down to earth where we all belong!
If I missed the point, it's because you so poorly explained yours.
"
As south-east asians, we should congratulate her for ambition, courage, and determination, and wish her a lot of success."
Clearly, if Daniel or Santino won, you would not have had the same feelings. You claimed to have wanted Chloe to win, but why? you mention nothing about her design capability, which is what the show is about.
Because you're twisting my words, I'll clarify.
Michael Kors is sucessful, but on what level? His designs are not only run-of-the mill, but they are mass produced for every girl who thinks she knows something about fashion. Nina Garcia of ELLE and her staff struggle everyday to keep up with competing with VOGUE, the true giant in the fashion industry. ELLE is copycat work, and their insight is laughable.
As soon as you bring up her nationality, you've already shown it's not all about her design. You should be congratulating her ONLY for her win, not for being a SE Asian refugee and winning. If you can't see the idocrity of that, then I guess ignorance really is bliss.
Let me put it in words you will understand. Your mind does not have the creativy knowledge to even begin to comprehend what a true artist is able to do. All you can see is the end result.
You want me to come back down to earth with you? When people know nothing of design, creativity, and consturction? Please. I'm much more comfortable where I am, laughing at your naivety.
QUOTE (Bounthy @ Mar 11 2006, 02:14 PM)

Chynagongju:
Oh, I see! She knows her $hit!
So, for whom she creates her design and to whom she will sell her cloth, and because of whom she may become a famous designer?
Wouldn't a designer designs cloth based on the taste and preference of customers? or are customers a just a bunch of "whatever" who will buy anything because a designer tells them what they should wear?
Why then American Idol relies entirely on polls from viewers to decide who will be eliminated and who will become an American Idol? Are those millions of viewers who vote an expert in singing and music?
I think there is a bit of misunderstanding on the definition of a real designer here!
Clearly, I know more sh!t than you.
No, a designer does NOT base their designs on what consumers want. Thats was a marketer, a business person does. You have it backwards. You dont even realize it, but everyone wears cloting because they are told they like it; you really think in the 80s, people enjoyed uncomfortable shoulder pads and sweaty leggings? No. Designers made the look, and the people followed. Open up your eyes.
American Idol? Tell me why Clay Aiken's sales have surpasses the rest of the final 12's CD sales, including Ruben? You think people know what they want... If they did, the sales would have reflected the results. THEY DIDN'T.
There most definitely IS a misunderstanding of a true designer. I'm truly sorry you can't understand what it really means.