Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: A female should be allowed to inherit the imperial throne?
Asia Finest Discussion Forum > Asian Culture > Japanese Chat
gogogo0
I am reading a document named "Japanese Women: Lineage and Legacies", by Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars
The question is simple: A female should be allowed to inherit the imperial throne?
But hard to answer.
"should" or "should not", it is a question.
What do you think about it?


IPB Image

The document Official link is here and here.
I found it in Asiaing.com, a free ebook site.
SoCal
QUOTE(gogogo0 @ Aug 22 2006, 09:44 PM) [snapback]2209669[/snapback]

I am reading a document named "Japanese Women: Lineage and Legacies", by Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars
The question is simple: A female should be allowed to inherit the imperial throne?
But hard to answer.
"should" or "should not", it is a question.
What do you think about it?
IPB Image

The document Official link is here and here.
I found it in Asiaing.com, a free ebook site.


United Kingdom has been allowing female heirs to inherit the throne and UK is doing fine.

I support it. icon_smile.gif
Tami
Originally women did inherit the throne. This whole male only thing occured pretty recently. I think it happened after the whities came over.
raspberry
From what I've read, there is a split in thought about this isssue. Many japanese want to keep tradition, but others feel that it's fine to have a female. I am not a native Japanese living in Japan so I think it's fine that a female rule.
supernovasp
QUOTE(Tami @ Aug 23 2006, 01:07 AM) [snapback]2209719[/snapback]

Originally women did inherit the throne. This whole male only thing occured pretty recently. I think it happened after the whities came over.

embarassedlaugh.gif
Ino
There has been a female emperor before, I forgot if it was one of the mythical rulers or an actual historical figure.

Empress Jingu, was an empress of Japan.
kunomchu
dynasty should die out.
supernovasp
QUOTE(kunomchu @ Aug 23 2006, 09:48 PM) [snapback]2212737[/snapback]

dynasty should die out.

i agree,
mochichuchu
QUOTE(Ino @ Aug 23 2006, 06:47 PM) [snapback]2212733[/snapback]


There has been a female emperor before,I forgot if it was one of the mythical rulers or an actual historical figure.



Wrong ..... Japan had 8 Empresses with 2 reigned twice according to my Chinese translated book titled " Chronology of Japan's Royal House ".
rahul1000
I say why the hell not?
MarieAntoinette
QUOTE(kunomchu @ Aug 23 2006, 09:48 PM) [snapback]2212737[/snapback]

dynasty should die out.


just cause china's died out doesnt mean the japanese one should die out. japanese people still take their imperial family seriously.
kunomchu
imperial family has dark secrets so they should die out.

what is your beef with chinese anyways? go hug a tree
RentonWong
It must be a Taiwanese thing.
MarieAntoinette
QUOTE(kunomchu @ Aug 23 2006, 10:25 PM) [snapback]2212878[/snapback]

imperial family has dark secrets so they should die out.

what is your beef with chinese anyways? go hug a tree


nothing. i am chinese and im proud of it. what i have a problem with is a bunch of non-japanese people coming in here and talking about whether or not Japan should have a female emperor. this is a sacred thing to them. we should have more respect. its not something non-japanese should just gossip about.
RentonWong
Japan needs a Female Empress who will marry either a Chinese or Korean man. God forbid if she ever marries a White Gaijin...
Takashi
QUOTE(Tami @ Aug 23 2006, 06:07 AM) [snapback]2209719[/snapback]

Originally women did inherit the throne. This whole male only thing occured pretty recently. I think it happened after the whities came over.

I agree with this. Changing it was pointless. The first Empress was in the Asuka period. mochichuchu is right in saying that there have been 8 in total with two reigning twice. There was a change in the law in 1947 but from 1771 there were no more female rulers.

Prince Tomohito think concubines should be brought back icon_rolleyes.gif
I suppose what will happen depends on what Princess Kiko manages to pop out in September.

QUOTE(RentonWong @ Aug 24 2006, 03:32 AM) [snapback]2212911[/snapback]

Japan needs a Female Empress who will marry either a Chinese or Korean man. God forbid if she ever marries a White Gaijin...

Hell no.
kunomchu
QUOTE(MarieAntoinette @ Aug 23 2006, 10:29 PM) [snapback]2212896[/snapback]

nothing. i am chinese and im proud of it. what i have a problem with is a bunch of non-japanese people coming in here and talking about whether or not Japan should have a female emperor. this is a sacred thing to them. we should have more respect. its not something non-japanese should just gossip about.


To me horohito was a war criminal. Many of the imperial family were also. I could care less about the japanese imperial family.
Takashi
QUOTE(kunomchu @ Aug 24 2006, 09:09 AM) [snapback]2214000[/snapback]

To me horohito was a war criminal. Many of the imperial family were also. I could care less about the japanese imperial family.

hirohito/shōwa
who else?
han2
don't see why not...rules are made to be modified, when the need arise.
Ino
QUOTE(mochichuchu @ Aug 23 2006, 09:54 PM) [snapback]2212757[/snapback]

Wrong ..... Japan had 8 Empresses with 2 reigned twice according to my Chinese translated book titled " Chronology of Japan's Royal House ".


How was i Wrong? I merely speculated that i thought an Empress had reigned before. sure.gif

QUOTE(RentonWong @ Aug 23 2006, 10:32 PM) [snapback]2212911[/snapback]

Japan needs a Female Empress who will marry either a Chinese or Korean man. God forbid if she ever marries a White Gaijin...


The Imperial Family will never allow a White to marry a descendant of Amaterasu. The Imperial Army is strict on issues of marriage, I mean, Princess Sayaka (i think) married a commoner and was renounced of her imperial title.
kvetch
QUOTE(kunomchu @ Aug 23 2006, 09:48 PM) [snapback]2212737[/snapback]

dynasty should die out.


agreed
Takashi
QUOTE(Ino @ Aug 24 2006, 12:54 PM) [snapback]2214311[/snapback]

How was i Wrong? I merely speculated that i thought an Empress had reigned before. sure.gif
The Imperial Family will never allow a White to marry a descendant of Amaterasu. The Imperial Army is strict on issues of marriage, I mean, Princess Sayaka (i think) married a commoner and was renounced of her imperial title.

Women get shafted in the Imperial family. If they marry commoners they lose their title and any claim to the throne whereas the men dont embarassedlaugh.gif Empress Michiko and Princess Kiko are/were both commoners.
Ino
QUOTE(Takashi @ Aug 24 2006, 11:47 AM) [snapback]2215013[/snapback]

Women get shafted in the Imperial family. If they marry commoners they lose their title and any claim to the throne whereas the men dont embarassedlaugh.gif Empress Michiko and Princess Kiko are/were both commoners.



damn you beat me to it, i was just about to say that laugh.gif
Majapahitans
Maybe Japan should dig back to prehistoric era and rediscover Japan's native culture.
Long before male-dominated military Shogunate era.
When female priest-shaman queen reign the island.
And I think it's the origin of Amaterasu O-mikami mythology.
komugi
no.
RentonWong
No means later.
komugi
Well, everything is ever-changing.. But I don't see it changing unless there is a extreme need to.. so I give it another 10 years.. if they see no sons... Then well... icon_smile.gif
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2009 Invision Power Services, Inc.