Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: SHOULD INDIA WORK FOR TIBET'S INDEPENDENCE
Asia Finest Discussion Forum > Asian Culture > India Chat
ReichsLeiter
tibet has historical and cultural links with india. right now there are thousands of tibetans living in india including their( also mine) supreme leader THE DALAI LAMA. So do you think india should work against beijing?
Tenjikuronin
Well, this issue is more complex than that.

Tibet and China have to solve their problems alone. India can't get involved because it is not within its realm of authority.

kunomchu
It would be stupid for india to get involved.
ReichsLeiter
then why are u all voting for yes??????
radha_chopra112
Tibet has historically been apart of the India, so yes we should! icon_smile.gif
Goombaking209
As long as india doesnt have intentions of annexing them then yes..
Korean Guy
yes an no.

1. tibet shouldn't belong to china.

2. tibet should be it's own free nation.

india doesn't want to start a conflict with china because china supports pakistan and vice versa.
Sirikittong
Tibet is already part of the People's Republic of China, the same as Sikkim is part of the Indian Republic. It would be unwise and undiplomatic for India to call for Tibet's independence, as it would strain the booming relationship with India and China.

China and India are the leaders of Asia-Pacific, and both should work together and evade quarells such as this.

Main goal: Modernization, increase human development index.

lama23
anyone would prefer tibet under India then those communist
rahul1000
From what I have heard, Tibetians want to be under India because of its freedom but also under China because of its better economy and infrastructure.
jiggyiggy
It's too late, I think Hans already outnumber Tibetans now. Except for meddling in it's religous affairs, I actually think Tibet is better off under China.
Bhusam
QUOTE(radha_chopra112 @ Sep 2 2006, 03:01 AM) *

Tibet has historically been apart of the India, so yes we should! icon_smile.gif

I think you stole that line from CCP officials....now back it up if you please.

QUOTE(rahul1000 @ Sep 2 2006, 08:53 AM) *

From what I have heard, Tibetians want to be under India because of its freedom but also under China because of its better economy and infrastructure.


First of all, Tibetans are not spelled the way you did. Secondly, what you said isn't true because I know how we feel.
gomeny
Honestly no, you don't want to start anything with crazy china. They're one step below suicide bomber crazy, and there is no need to get into a war with country that is willing destroys its legitimacy to gain control of an island that it has tenuous claim to.
SuperiorHominid
Tibet is South and Central Asian. Not East Asian. It should be free
Suijen
Why would this even be an issue for India?

If India recognizes the independent Tibetan government, then China won't recognize India. If you try to take the territory by force, China will respond by force.

From what you gain and what you lose, your results would be pretty one-sided.
gomeny
QUOTE(SuperiorHominid @ Sep 2 2006, 05:55 PM) *

Tibet is South and Central Asian. Not East Asian. It should be free

That's really pie in the sky answer. There own spiritual leader is to be busy meeting foreign dignitaries and Hollywood celebrities. I really wonder if he cares about Tibet.
PervertBurger
QUOTE
then China won't recognize India


That kind of a silly thing to do, even if India did recognize Tibet. Plus, it would look childish on China's rap sheet with other nations. I say if India recognizes Tibet as a independent state, so be it. India wouldn't help them besides letting Tibetans stay in their country.
rahul1000
India COULD get involved, but then China would be so on its @$$ and thats the last thing it needs right now.
Suijen
QUOTE(PervertBurger @ Sep 2 2006, 07:03 PM) *

That kind of a silly thing to do, even if India did recognize Tibet. Plus, it would look childish on China's rap sheet with other nations. I say if India recognizes Tibet as a independent state, so be it. India wouldn't help them besides letting Tibetans stay in their country.


Considering that China does that with countries that recognize Taiwan, I certaintly wouldn't doubt it.
gomeny
QUOTE(rahul1000 @ Sep 2 2006, 06:03 PM) *

India COULD get involved, but then China would be so on its @$$ and thats the last thing it needs right now.

Honestly would be worth it for the massive zerg rush of froglees and JayChou2's that would attack India?
Tenjikuronin
QUOTE(Suijen @ Sep 2 2006, 05:59 PM) *

Why would this even be an issue for India?

If India recognizes the independent Tibetan government, then China won't recognize India. If you try to take the territory by force, China will respond by force.

From what you gain and what you lose, your results would be pretty one-sided.



Well, in 2005 China finally recognized Sikkim as an Indian state and as such India responded by officially recognizing Tibet as a Chinese province. Neither side was going to take action on either issue.

I can see China recognizing Arunachal Pardesh as an Indian state in the near future, because it would be highly unbenefitial for China to take any military action on the matter.
gomeny
QUOTE(Tenjikuronin @ Sep 2 2006, 06:07 PM) *

Well, in 2005 China finally recognized Sikkim as an Indian state and as such India responded by officially recognizing Tibet as a Chinese province. Neither side was going to take action on either issue.

I can see China recognizing Arunachal Pardesh as an Indian state in the near future, because it would be highly unbenefitial for China to take any military action on the matter.

if they don't India can send a zerg rush of Dharmasen's to China
Suijen
QUOTE(gomeny @ Sep 2 2006, 07:09 PM) *

if they don't India can send a zerg rush of Dharmasen's to China


fu-k that, we'll zerg rush you back.
Tenjikuronin
QUOTE(gomeny @ Sep 2 2006, 06:09 PM) *

if they don't India can send a zerg rush of Dharmasen's to China

Froglee would probably have a heart attack.

QUOTE(Suijen @ Sep 2 2006, 06:11 PM) *

fu-k that, we'll zerg rush you back.

Lol, looks like Suijen didn't get the inside joke..... embarassedlaugh.gif
gomeny
QUOTE(Tenjikuronin @ Sep 2 2006, 06:11 PM) *

Froglee would probably have a heart attack.

Froglee would blame the American editorial writers

Either way if we recognize Tibet they need to recognize Arunachal Pradesh
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.