Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Manchuria is part of China, not Korea!
Asia Finest Discussion Forum > Asian Culture > Korean Chat > Korean Serious Talk
RogerFederer
I don't know why some Korea want to claim other's land. icon_twisted.gif



Sea of Japan -> East Sea (How many East Sea in the World)

East Sea (China) -> South Sea

Yellow Sea -> West Sea



Korea is a SELF-CENTRED race. biggthumpup.gif
sekushii
Korea never claimed Manchuria.
heavymetalsamurai
actually china is apart of manchuria, but I wont go into that...icon_smile.gif
kunomchu
QUOTE(heavymetalsamurai @ Oct 24 2006, 04:27 AM) *

actually china is apart of manchuria, but I wont go into that...icon_smile.gif


please do enlighten us on the great people's republic of manchuria laugh.gif
RogerFederer
QUOTE(kunomchu @ Oct 24 2006, 03:28 AM) *

please do enlighten us on the great people's republic of manchuria laugh.gif



Imperial Japanese Empire is a rubbish evil empire.
Mua
idiot !!no korean claims manchuria except for a few freaks...the only claims are cultural ones and those are totally justified you prick!
Titanium
QUOTE(heavymetalsamurai @ Oct 24 2006, 03:27 AM) *

actually china is apart of manchuria, but I wont go into that...icon_smile.gif

Which is fine with us as long as the two lands are connected and within our jurisdiction.
Ino_II
I dont think any Korean says MANCHURIA is korea's land... it belongs to China currently.

HanulSky
QUOTE(Mua @ Oct 24 2006, 11:17 AM) *

idiot !!no korean claims manchuria except for a few freaks...the only claims are cultural ones and those are totally justified you prick!


I agree with Mua. Gojosoen had cultural ties to manchuria, but that was 4,000 years ago.
Mid-Night_Sun
this is so dumb...some random fool is going to make a thread and say some stupid shyt like that. he doesnt even have quotes or proof ANYONE has claimed anything.

he skips that and goes and proves w/e the fuk. then some people are going to come and actually argue. (actually, its amazing there are serious posts) its so unbelievable its midly amusing.
T98G
QUOTE(Ino_II @ Oct 24 2006, 08:53 PM) *

I dont think any Korean says MANCHURIA is korea's land... it belongs to China currently.

Why the word currently nono.gif
ekkenergy
QUOTE(HanulSky @ Oct 24 2006, 08:56 PM) *

I agree with Mua. Gojosoen had cultural ties to manchuria, but that was 4,000 years ago.


Korea has 4,000 year history? laugh.gif
donthateonboca
yes korea is one of the oldest civilizations according to wikipedia.
HanulSky
QUOTE(donthateonboca @ Oct 25 2006, 12:03 AM) *

yes korea is one of the oldest civilizations according to wikipedia.


according to wikipedia, gojoseon came from the tungustic peoples.

QUOTE
The people of Gojoseon belonged to the Tungusic family and were linguistically affiliated with the Altaic. They propagated in Manchuria, far eastern China, north of the Yangtze River, and the Korean Peninsula. Gojoseon eventually consolidated in lower Manchuria and the Korean Peninsula. The people of Gojeoson were recorded as Dongyi (東夷) in Chinese, meaning ""eastern barbarians". The expression is also interpreted as "eastern bowmen", because 夷 consists of "弓" (bow) and "人" (man).


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gojoseon
SagaciousLuDa
use wikipedia as a source? LOL embarassedlaugh.gif
donthateonboca
wikis awesome man. why not. sure they have flaws but which website doesn't.
ekkenergy
QUOTE(donthateonboca @ Oct 24 2006, 09:03 PM) *

according to wikipedia.


when was korean written system invented? how was the first dynasty in korea founded?
Mid-Night_Sun
you know what...i own manchuria...
kaizen
And I own North pole.
MING-LOYALIST

Manchuria is northeast China.

As sekushii said Koreans don't have a claim on manchuria nor do they claim it.

This thread is absolutely pointless.
northwestern_student
how about we drive out all the chinese from manchuria and let it become it's own country icon_twisted.gif
kunomchu
how about we close this retarded thread. Mods?
MING-LOYALIST
QUOTE(northwestern_student @ Oct 25 2006, 01:00 AM) *

how about we drive out all the chinese from manchuria and let it become it's own country icon_twisted.gif

How about you cut your d!ck off so it can be independent organ.icon_twisted.gif
kaiwen
China is not Korea
Konji
fu-k you all. of course manchuria was part of dongyi. And it was part of the japanese empire in the 1800s century. before that it was not sinicized. they had their own language, which is manchurian.

of course now none of them speak manchurian anymore, it's a dead fu-ken language. geez. I hate the chinese. trying to erase peoples cultures by making everyone chinese.

Manchuria should be an independent state. they have no cultural links to chinese culture. so fu-k free manchuria.
deep impact
QUOTE(Konji @ Oct 25 2006, 03:24 AM) *

fu-k you all. of course manchuria was part of dongyi. And it was part of the japanese empire. Manchuria should be an independent state. they have no cultural links to chinese culture. so fu-k free manchuria.


dong-yi shares a cultural sphere with korea.
Konji
QUOTE(northwestern_student @ Oct 25 2006, 02:00 AM) *

how about we drive out all the chinese from manchuria and let it become it's own country icon_twisted.gif


yes, but it's too late, only a handful of people speak manchurian.
deep impact
QUOTE(Konji @ Oct 25 2006, 03:31 AM) *

yes, but it's too late, only a handful of people speak manchurian.


hah? what are you getting? aren't we talking about history?
Konji
QUOTE(deep impact @ Oct 25 2006, 04:50 AM) *

hah? what are you getting? aren't we talking about history?


i was just responding to northwestern. he said to chase chinese people out of manchuria, but manchurians don't speak manchurian anymore. After they became assimulated to china, the new generations only speak mandarin chinese fluently, so they are basically speak mandarin, write in mandarin... So it's like you can't turn back the clock.
grunt
QUOTE(Konji @ Oct 25 2006, 04:57 AM) *

i was just responding to northwestern. he said to chase chinese people out of manchuria, but manchurians don't speak manchurian anymore. After they became assimulated to china, the new generations only speak mandarin chinese fluently, so they are basically speak mandarin, write in mandarin... So it's like you can't turn back the clock.


i'll have to agree with Konji. Manchurians are different ethnic people from han chinese. China systematically destroyed the culture and language of manchurians. Now, there is no more manchurians in the region. In a sense, this is more cruel than some facism regin such as nazi or stalinism. In canada, when british conquered french Qubec, they at least let the french preserve their culture and language. Actually, it's pretty insulting that chinese just erased all the memory of manchurian culture and language.
MadGhoul
what the fu-k are you idiots babbling about, nothing would've happened to the Manchurians if they didn't invade China and set up the Qing dynasty. Manchurians willingly took up the culture and the language because they knew that the only way to rule China was to adopt its culture, which doesn't mean that they forgot theirs. thats why the Manchus succeeded and the Mongols failed in the Yuan Dynasty.

and not only that, Manchurians still speak Manchurian specifically in Heilongjin. my friend is Manju and he speaks it and was bred and born there. as a matter of fact there are schools their that preserve it and teach it and right now there is a resurgence in Manchu culture which the government does not object to.

so go fu-k yourselves for talking out of your @$$
Suren911
tons of manchus alive and well nowadays. the culture is quite alive and so is the language.
Morgan25
"The Chinese Academy of Social Sciences, which is under the direct jurisdiction of the Chinese government, asserts that the history of not only the ancient Korean kingdom of Koguryo but also of Gija-Chosun, Puyo and Barhae all belong to Chinese history, and so do their territories." thumbsdown.gif
Who's claiming who's land now? confused.gif
Whoever started this thread probably agrees with CASS and must be some demented Chinese nationalist. This is worse than the France/Germany deal with Alsace-Lorraine.
Titanium
The Manchus chose to get involved in China. They were the ones who invaded and started their own dynasty so now I ask of you, how is it even logical to accuse the Chinese of being imperialistic towards the Manchus?

Oh and BTW according to professor Endymion Wilkinson, the Dongyi peoples were actually Austronesian speaking peoples who inhabited eastern coastal China. Just some food for thought.
Cha
I met a Chosunjok travel guide. He owned part of Manchuria.
bigboy
didn't korea control most of manchuria in the kingdom times? Iono, i'm not very good with history. I think i've seen a map though.
Konji
what does manchurian sound like? I never heard manchurian before.
LiaodongProvince(Josen)
QUOTE(bigboy @ Oct 26 2006, 09:11 PM) *

didn't korea control most of manchuria in the kingdom times? Iono, i'm not very good with history. I think i've seen a map though.


maybe in your dream? embarassedlaugh.gif embarassedlaugh.gif j/k
kunomchu
QUOTE(Konji @ Oct 25 2006, 04:24 AM) *

fu-k you all. of course manchuria was part of dongyi. And it was part of the japanese empire in the 1800s century. before that it was not sinicized. they had their own language, which is manchurian.

of course now none of them speak manchurian anymore, it's a dead fu-ken language. geez. I hate the chinese. trying to erase peoples cultures by making everyone chinese.

Manchuria should be an independent state. they have no cultural links to chinese culture. so fu-k free manchuria.


lo you are dumbass.
LVF
another Tibet case?
LiaodongProvince(Josen)
QUOTE(LVF @ Oct 26 2006, 10:06 PM) *

another Tibet case?


IPB Image

is that your pic? you look cute. love2.gif love2.gif icon_redface.gif
nkekr
QUOTE(Konji @ Oct 25 2006, 03:24 AM) *

fu-k you all. of course manchuria was part of dongyi. And it was part of the japanese empire in the 1800s century. before that it was not sinicized. they had their own language, which is manchurian.

of course now none of them speak manchurian anymore, it's a dead fu-ken language. geez. I hate the chinese. trying to erase peoples cultures by making everyone chinese.

Manchuria should be an independent state. they have no cultural links to chinese culture. so fu-k free manchuria.


How about fu-k no? And it's not called fu-king "Manchuria," get that fu-king straight first, aight? Our region is called DONGBEI, NOT SOME DOG$hit WESTERN NAME CALLED "Manchuria." Dong Yi my @$$. Part of japanese empire MY @$$, by the way, you should check your own history. Dongbei is part of China, you Koreans of ALL people have the LEAST say in how we DongBei Ren define ourselves. 100% Chinese baby, fu-k yeah!
kunomchu
Shes the same idiot that said chinese names are ugly. Idiot troll
LVF
QUOTE(LiaodongProvince(Josen) @ Oct 26 2006, 11:07 PM) *

IPB Image

is that your pic? you look cute. love2.gif love2.gif icon_redface.gif

yea lol thanks

QUOTE(kunomchu @ Oct 26 2006, 11:17 PM) *

Shes the same idiot that said chinese names are ugly. Idiot troll

confused.gif I hope you're not talking about me. I never said that.
kunomchu
QUOTE(LVF @ Oct 26 2006, 11:23 PM) *


confused.gif I hope you're not talking about me. I never said that.


not u lol

Konji

donthateonboca
QUOTE(LiaodongProvince(Josen) @ Oct 26 2006, 06:57 PM) *

maybe in your dream? embarassedlaugh.gif embarassedlaugh.gif j/k


go show off chinese dominance somwhere else? embarassedlaugh.gif embarassedlaugh.gif icon_confused.gif
Error101
are you guys f--king serious?
some random dude said some stupid f--k. so what?
pls get the facts right also...aight? f--king ridiculous.....
Jasel
Requested
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2009 Invision Power Services, Inc.