These 2 teen stars r huge now,which 1 do u guys prefer?
i'll go 4 lindsay,her acting skills r much better then hilary,her vocal voice is more powerful then hilary,u just cant deny the fact that lindsay is more talented,and more sucessful then hilary duff.and she's much slimmer then the fat-turkey-hilary...

ahh I like them both

who cares what their body types are? i thought you said most "talented"

wasnt there another poll like this? either way i say hillary.. she's just absolutely adorable. She keeps it real. She seems very friendly and humble. She still has the innocence even though she's big...

lohan, she drinks/smokes. she just seems so caught up in the superficial world... yes she skinnier but hillary still looks better. believe it or not, most guys perfer girls who are a little thick(not fat) than really skinny.

I like Lindsay Lohan, because she makes pretty good movies. And I think Hilary is pretty but her eye liner is overdone a lot.

i'd do both at the same time. that would be nice

ahhhhh k....

Lindsay Lohan is a straight up b!tch in real life. She acts better I suppose but I hate actors who are assholes in reality like Russel Crowe.

man i hate how hilary duff is trying to bring in her sister to hollywood... that sucks how hollywood actors/actress try to get their whole family famous....

even their dogs!!!!

ya like Britney Spears' sister Jamie on the Nick show "All That"(which she isn't by the way...)

god,how can guys like hilary's figure,can u see?she's overweight and fat,look at the size of her arm
if guys love hilary's figure,i bet that they will love america coz 60% of the residents there r overwieght,unhealthy,fat,and probably have heart diseases,obesities....

and oh yeah,i have heard hilary and her big sis,haylie sang 2gether in the song,our lips r sealed.its sounds horrible,1 duff is enough but 2 duffes!!

i would hardly consider either lindsay or hillary as being "obese". they're young, it's probably baby fat.

Well they both dont look that good to me fat or not. I luv red hair but I'm not to fond of blonde. Especially that bright blonde hair that she has

They both suck.

what he said

Lindsey Lohan is Hot

there's a difference between fat and thick. hillary is a little thick i'll admit but eh you'd be suprised A LOT of guys like the girls a little thick.

sorry to admit it, but my neice who is 4 years old and i both like lindsey and hilary. my neice chants....lizzie meewire.

^ ha, i pick you anyday ....

i like lindsey body and cute face same for hillary...

^haha. i'd pick you any day too barney...hahhaa

^ oh really? hahaha oyou like it huh?


anyway back on topic, did anybody catch lndsay on snl 4-5 weeks ago?

uhh i dont really like them both that much lol....but id say lindsay lohan over hilary duff...i dont like hilary duff at alllll

Yup, Lindsay. She's got a bod now too (heard the boobs might be fake though).

Linday Lohan for me please.

fake is better than none, haha, jk
Anyways, i do not like both, lindsay nor hilary much

I like them both I think they are pretty girls & talented at ACTING. Not singing...everyone cannot be singer, sorry.

How is Hilary Duff fat? Wow. I just don't see it. How skinny do people want girls to be? Let me guess 6'1 105 LBS? ...Disgusting.

^^^ i guess they like the anorexic look

I like Lindsay and her two sweater puppies.

i could careless about these two.. but if i had to chose then i would chose lindsay because her music is way better then hilary's and also her movies are more entertaining..

Hilary stole Lindsay's bf Aaron Carter, so I'd have 2 pick Lindsay. Hilary may look sweet but looks can be deceiving.

I think Lindsay Lohan has more potential in acting than Hilary Duff (who should stop singing because she can't)

here's an interesting article i found..
http://channels.netscape.com/ns/celebrity/...t/lohan_vs_duff
hillary is so much better

edit

They actually despise each other in real life. Forgot where I read about it though but was very interesting.

yes bcoz hillary stole linday's bf. and maybe also coz theyr kinda competing with one another (?)

something like that. and Linsday Lohan basically started her music career to try to knock hillary out of the spotlight. I'm sorry I just hate Linsday because of her b!tch attitude. Alot of people who've had to work for her even say she's a b!tch.

this is the perfect example of how personality can make or break someone.
To me they both look equally good, i'd say an 8 out of 10.
But then factoring in personality it makes lohan like a 6 while it makes hillary a 9-9.5. I just find her adorable. If someone asked me what type of girls i like, she'd be the perfect example. "Party girl? Doesn't like drinking or the nightlife." how awesome is that...

i'll say both of them

You have to like their types of movies to really like them. I used to like Hillary Duff more but now i just think she is a little to full of herself. Lindsey is pretty good but her movies havent been doing well. So, really i dunno...

I think Linsdays problem is she's doing to many movies. She needs to slow down a little so people can actually look forward to seeing her.

the first pic indicates spring - 2003
the second pic indicates summer - 2004

Hilary Duff is growing up (and out) right before our eyes. The 16-year-old starlet, who is busy filming The Perfect Man with Heather Locklear in Toronto, appears to have gained a few extra pounds. "In the first picture, she's probably around 115 to 118 pounds," speculates Dr. Howard Shapiro, a New York City weight-loss specialist who has never treated Duff. "Now she looks closer to 130 to 140 pounds. That's a significant gain for her." But her publicist insists there isn't one extra ounce of her to love. "Hilary has not gained any weight and her clothing size has not changed," her rep tells Star. "Perhaps the scarf she has around her middle and the angle of the photo [in Star magazine] give the illusion of a weight gain, but that's not the case." You decide!


she gained weight!!!! no doubt about it..... and her publicist is trying to deny it.... losers!!!!


hilary is just a ugly, fat, slutty, and a suck up lil girl (my opinion)

Ack ya she put on a few pounds but at her age she could lose it fast enough. Dont really think she's ugly or much of a slut but I'd still put her over Lohan(well not in looks right now, she'll have to lose some weight first)

I don't really like both of 'em. But I guess Lindsay is prettier.

I had no idea that Lindsay has a music career...>.>

i don't see anything really wrong with Hillary duff's weight. She's pretty the way she is right now, and her body looks a lot better too than the Olsen twins who have stick bodies.

i dont know, lindsay is hotter but duff is more of a "take home to mom" type, so innocent lookn

thank ya for saying what i wanted to say

christy carlson romano is hottter than both of them combined!

Hilary Duff any day!

pics....